• 59°

John Hood: What is government’s role anyway?

Columnist

John Hood

By John Hood

RALEIGH — Very few conservatives are “anti-government.”

We believe government should be limited in scope, in order to maximize the freedom to make your own decisions and live according to your own values. But we also recognize that protecting that freedom is impossible without government.

By definition, that means coercion. What distinguishes government from the other social institutions that make up a society isn’t public spiritedness or organizational flowcharts or periodic elections. Other institutions have one or more of those features. What makes government unique is that if you do not fund and obey it, you can be fined or arrested. For conservatives, government turns tyrannical when push comes to shove, when it exceeds its proper, constitutional bounds.

If you think “government should” and “society should” are indistinguishable ways of beginning a sentence, it will be challenging for us to have a conversation about politics. We have a language barrier.

I believe human beings have many moral obligations to each other. In most cases, however, your failure to discharge your moral obligation cannot justify me or anyone else using force to compel your obedience. Aggregating all of us as individuals into “society” doesn’t change the calculation of justice. We can ask you to do the right thing, we can present arguments and evidence in an effort to convince you. But to resort to force would be to treat you as less than a moral agent, as less than fully human.

Some people take this line of argument so far that they deny a role for government at all in a just society. They are mistaken. Government is inevitable and necessary because human beings are flawed creatures with temptations, inherent in our unchangeable human natures, to break the very rules that allow civilization to flourish.

There has always been violence. There has always been envy. Indeed, there has been and will always be good-faith differences of opinion about the practical application of the rights to one’s life, liberty and pursuit of happiness. Sometimes they will escalate into debilitating and dangerous violence.

Government’s proper role, then, is to maximize freedom. That means passing laws and issuing rules that define and uphold our rights, deter and punish acts of force and fraud, and facilitate private, voluntary agreements. It means safeguarding the interests of those who are not in a position to conduct their own affairs, such as minor children and those with severe disabilities.

Most conservatives also believe that means ensuring the provision of certain public goods that make a free society functional and sustainable, such as education.

Conservatives frequently disagree among themselves about the details, naturally. And in recent years, some have even argued that modern American conservatism has put too great an emphasis on freedom at the expense of community cohesion, moral standards or national greatness.

Still, if you would understand the origins of today’s most contentious public disputes — from Medicaid expansion and fiscal policy in North Carolina to Medicare for All and religious liberty in national politics — you have to start with the basics. At root, these disputes aren’t about facts and figures. They spring from differences in definitions.

Does that mean conservatives and progressives have nothing of consequence to say to each other? No. We can debate specific policy alternatives, perhaps finding instances of agreement. At the very least, the conversation may lead to less mutual recrimination and demonization, which would be most welcome.

John Hood is chairman of the John Locke Foundation.

Comments

Education

A.L. Brown celebrates seniors with signing day

Business

Rebounding, but not recovered: Rowan County tourism begins challenging path toward normalcy

High School

High school baseball: Padgett leads Mustangs; 100th win for West coach Graham

Coronavirus

RSS superintendent, Board of Health discuss strategies for increasing student vaccination rates

Nation/World

Gas stations report shortages as pipeline shutdown drags on

News

Lawyers: Black man didn’t drive into deputies who shot him

Nation/World

Liz Cheney says Trump and GOP backers threaten democracy

Coronavirus

Rowan Health Department clarifies county’s COVID-19 death total is 301

Landis

Landis approves new land development ordinance, zoning map

Landis

Landis approves body camera, stun gun purchase for public safety officers

Crime

One charged, another dead on sheriff’s most wanted list

Crime

No injuries after car shot eight times on Old Concord Road

Education

RSS talks first steps for new federal relief totaling $66 million

China Grove

Gary’s Barbecue staff, customers look back at 50 years

News

Salisbury Lions Club names Person of the Year, Lion of the Year at 78th annual banquet

Education

Student COVID-19 numbers show first decline since plan A

High School

High school golf: Fowler competes in state tournament

News

Amazon announces new distribution center for North Carolina

News

House passes bill to bar Cooper from mandating COVID shot

Coronavirus

Rowan County sees death 302 from COVID-19; Health Department to host final mass vaccine clinic

Ask Us

Ask Us: What happened to work on South Fulton Street home?

Crime

Blotter: Woman says she was shot in hand on Lincolnton Road

Crime

Rowan Sheriff’s Office charges Salisbury man with operating illegal gambling business

Crime

Blotter: Rockwell man arrested on felony drug, breaking and entering charges