• 84°

Commentary: Taming the tweeter in chief

The Washington Post

President Donald Trump on Thursday convened a “summit” on social media at the White House, where right-wing provocateurs (and not a single significant internet firm) gathered to decry what they perceive as top companies’ systematic censorship of conservative viewpoints. Days earlier, a federal appeals court ruled that Trump’s proclivity for blocking his critics on Twitter amounts to …. unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination.

The court decision denying Trump the ability to shut out people whose opinions offend him is a victory for openness and expression. Trump treats his account like a government channel, announcing policies from firings and hirings to a ban on transgender troops to, only last week, his administration’s intention to pursue putting a citizenship question on the decennial census.

His own employees have pronounced the account a source of official proclamations, and its interactive features — users can view, retweet and reply to his tweets and the attached comments — constitute a forum that is generally open to the population at large. Trump chooses to exclude people from that forum solely on the basis of what they believe.

The ruling is likely to have implications for holders of office less high than the commander in chief’s. Already, lawsuits have been filed against Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and another appeals court earlier this year prevented a Virginia politician from kicking commenters off her Facebook page.

The outcome in each case should depend primarily on whether an account can be reasonably understood to be professional or personal, private or public, based on how it is used and who uses it. But there are other questions worth asking, such as whether officials can act against categories of speech such as violent threats or otherwise limit who participates in an online space.

Meanwhile, even as Trump tries to shut out those who take issue with his tweets, he persists in his crusade against social media sites in the name of free speech. “We have terrible bias. We have censorship like nobody has any understanding,” Trump said in a tirade against the tech companies after Thursday’s meeting.

Claims that Silicon Valley’s liberal leaders program their platforms to hurt the right and help the left are not supported by the evidence; in fact, the data show that conservative media has an easier time making stories go viral. The president’s philosophy toward the web, it seems, amounts to little more than this: People who agree with him should be allowed to speak, while those who disagree do not deserve a hearing.

Thursday’s summit was described as an effort to confront “the opportunities and challenges” of the internet. That’s a worthwhile topic, just as it is worthwhile for Congress and the executive branch to scrutinize companies’ policies on disinformation, privacy and more. But the president’s focus on personal gripes rather than policy problems threatens good-faith efforts to grapple with an industry that lawmakers have too long ignored.

Comments

Crime

Blotter: Gold Hill man charged with statutory rape

Crime

Man charged with killing 28-year-old found dead in crashed car

Crime

68-year-old woman identified as Jackson Street murder victim

Crime

Man arrested in Jacksonville for Salisbury murder

Local

Rowan-Salisbury Schools finalizes normal, five-day schedule for fall

Local

Council to vote on budget, consider permit for child care center near downtown

Landis

Landis adopts budget with reduction in residential electric rates, no tax increases

Local

Political Notebook: Budd campaign touts boost in voter support after Trump endorsement

Local

Seventh Dragon Boat Festival scheduled July 24

News

NC rights groups say GOP bills impede voting access

Local

Sgt. Shane Karriker’s funeral procession travels through downtown Salisbury

Crime

Blotter: June 14

Ask Us

Ask Us: When will front entrance to courthouse reopen?

Coronavirus

As COVID-19 cases wane, vaccine-lagging areas still at risk

Crime

Blotter: Man faces litany of charges for fleeing sheriff’s deputies

Granite Quarry

‘Race to the Dan’ brings Revolutionary War back to Rowan

Local

‘Unity in the Community’ event brings together Salisbury Police, NAACP

Crime

One killed, two others shot on South Jackson Street in Salisbury

Crime

State examining Davidson County emergency alert received in Rowan, other counties

Local

Cleveland Rodeo packs house for 10th year

News

Salisbury’s Jacques Belliveau talks mental health, filming during premiere of ‘Reggie: A Millennial Depression Comedy’

News

Sen. Ford backs new set of election-related bills

Business

Downtown Salisbury bullish on potential for more residential space

Business

Biz Roundup: Wine about Winter set for June 18