• 55°

County legislators disagree with judge’s ruling on constitutional amendments

SALISBURY — Because they received approval from the state’s voters, Rowan County’s state legislators say they disagree with a judge’s ruling on Friday that the General Assembly should not have added state constitutional amendments requiring voter ID and limiting income tax rates to the November ballot.

On Friday, Wake County Superior Court Judge Bryan Collins agreed with the state NAACP’s argument that the Republican-led General Assembly in 2017-18 was “illegally constituted” because federal judges had ruled that the district maps used in the the 2016 elections were gerrymandered based on race. 

“An illegally constituted General Assembly does not represent the people of North Carolina and is therefore not empowered to pass legislation that would amend the state’s Constitution,” Collins’ decision states.

Republican legislative leaders appealed the court ruling Monday night.

Rep. Harry Warren, R-76, said he thinks the judge erred in his decision because the ruling would mean that every bill and budget passed in the previous session would be invalid.

Warren and other lawmakers representing Rowan County — Rep. Julia Howard, R-77; Rep. Larry Pittman, R-83; and Sen. Carl Ford, R-33 — say they don’t think the ruling is legitimate because a majority of North Carolina voters approved the amendments. The amendment requiring a photo ID to vote received 55.5 percent approval; the amendment capping the income tax rate at 7 percent received 57.4 percent of the vote.

“The people of the state voted for the amendments,” Howard said. “This is overriding the voice of the people.”

Ford said he expected the amendments to be struck down based on Democrats’ plan to tie up the issue in court.

Whether the constitutional amendments will stand through the legal battles is unknown, as is the effect on future elections, especially whether voters will have to show an ID or not. Ford said he hopes the ruling won’t affect municipal elections in November, adding sometimes cases can take months or years to go through the courts.

Ford said judges, though, may be able to draw from Georgia’s voter registration law, which was adopted by a GOP-run legislature. Though the Georgia law was challenged in federal district court. 

Warren said voters backed the amendments struck down Friday even as they faced statewide campaigns against the amendments. He added that amendments received support from both Republicans and Democrats

Ford said the judge’s ruling is more reason for having nonpartisan judges. Collins is a registered Democrat.

Howard said Collins overstepped his authority with the decision.

“It’s sad here we have judges that legislate from the bench,” Howard said.

Pittman said he is outraged by the judge’s ruling.

“This judicial activism must come to an end,” Pittman said. “There is clear precedent that even if the courts disagree with the composition of a legislature due to redistricting, they do not seek to deny the legislature the right to govern while that issue is being addressed.”

Senate Leader Phil Berger had similar sentiments in a statement released Friday.

“Based on tonight’s opinion and others over the past several years, it appears the idea of judicial restrain has completely left the state of North Carolina,” Berger said.

The Associated Press contributed to this story.

Comments

Elections

Republicans on defense in state congressional races

Coronavirus

As officials face second wave of COVID-19, some resisting steps to curb virus

Business

Biz Roundup: Spalding wins state Executive of the Year award for work as Chamber president

Coronavirus

State health officials ease shutdown for church that had 181 COVID-19 cases

News

South Carolina tribe presents casino plan for Kings Mountain

News

Rockingham County ordered to reopen voting site

Racing

Michael Jordan’s NASCAR team partners with Joe Gibbs, Toyota

News

Zeta-caused landslide creates 90-mile detour in Mitchell, McDowell counties

BREAKING NEWS

Rowan County banking icon and community catalyst Paul Fisher dies

Coronavirus

State reports 20 COVID-19 cases at Rockwell Christian School, outbreak at Brightmoor Nursing Center

China Grove

Southern Rowan Christmas Parade to go on with COVID-19 safety measures in place

Local

Cress named Rowan County Emergency Services chief

Crime

Blotter: Two vehicles stolen after being left running

Nation/World

Six dead as Zeta soaks Gulf Coast and Southeast

Elections

Black Lives Matter signs will remain up at Carrboro polling site

Nation/World

Hackers snag $2.3 million from Wisconsin Republican Party

China Grove

In Senate race, Ford doubles cash on hand; Townsend spends $10,000 in House campaign

Elections

Two who attended rally for Trump in Gastonia test positive for COVID-19

Elections

Storm hinders Tillis events; Cunningham campaign activities remain quiet

Local

Trump-supporting organization to have downtown ‘Trump Train Parade’

Local

Spencer planning Christmas festivities for Dec. 12

Crime

Blotter: Rockwell man charged with removing electronic ankle monitor

Coronavirus

County’s rate of tests returning positive continues to decrease, still above 7%

BREAKING NEWS

UPDATED: Three charged in connection with drive-by shooting, vehicle pursuit