Prosecutor, attorneys fail to schedule Parsons murder trial
Published 12:00 am Thursday, November 1, 2018
SALISBURY — After an extended back-and-forth during a Wednesday morning hearing, Rowan County District Attorney Brandy Cook and attorneys for Sandy and Casey Parsons failed to set a date for the couple’s trial on charges of murdering their adopted daughter.
Cook went into the hearing ready to schedule a date, but attorneys Robert Campbell of Taylorsville and Vincent Rabil of Winston-Salem both said it would not be possible to begin given their current schedules and lack of time to review a multitude of trial documents.
Campbell and Patricia Riddick of Mooresville will represent Casey Parsons. Rabil and Tom King of Salisbury, a former prosecutor now in private practice, will represent Sandy Parsons.
Since 2013, the Parsonses had been under investigation by the Rowan County Sheriff’s Office after their biological son, Jamie, reported that he had not seen his sister, Erica, in two years. The couple told authorities then that Erica went to live with her biological grandmother, Irene Goodman.
The girl’s biological family, including her mother, Carolyn Parsons, said there was no Irene Goodman.
Investigators searched the couple’s home on Miller Chapel Road, their parents’ homes and other homes where they had lived over the years.
The pair were convicted in 2015 on charges that they continued to receive adoption assistance after Erica went missing. Casey Parsons also was convicted of trying to avoid IRS garnishment of any money she would have received if Erica were listed as a dependent on her tax returns.
Jamie Parsons testified in court that he witnessed his parents abuse Erica and that he participated in that abuse.
In February 2016, Sandy Parsons sought out Rowan County sheriff’s Detective Chad Moose and told him that Erica was dead. He told the detective that Erica’s body was disposed of on Dec. 18, 2011. Sandy Parsons led detectives about 80 miles from Salisbury to Chesterfield County, South Carolina, where human remains were found buried.
On Sept. 30, 2016, the N.C. Medical Examiner’s Office identified the bones as Erica’s. On Jan. 9, an autopsy report said the medical examiner had determined that Erica died of homicidal violence of undetermined means.
The autopsy also revealed that Erica may have been suffering from an untreated infection or sepsis, renal failure, poisoning or rhabdomyolysis (a breakdown of muscle that releases a damaging protein into the blood).
Until February, the couple were in federal prison serving time on mail fraud, tax fraud and other convictions. Both were indicted for murder by a Rowan County grand jury in mid-February. They were charged by local authorities and brought back to Rowan County to face charges of felony first-degree murder, obstruction of justice, concealment of a death and child abuse inflicting serious injuries.
They have been in the Rowan County Detention Center since March, held without bond.
Cook began Wednesday by explaining to Superior Court Judge Anna Mills Wagoner that the trial date was originally supposed to be addressed earlier this month but there was a conflict with the attorneys’ schedules.
“The purpose of today is to schedule a trial date,” Cook said.
Cook provided Wagoner with a recap of when the couple were indicted and when her office sent documents and other records of the investigation.
“We need to set a trial date,” Cook said emphatically.
She said many trials are held up by unprocessed lab results, but that is not a problem in this case.
Campbell said he’d never known a murder trial to be scheduled so early in the process.
“We still don’t have all of the discovery (documents), and that’s hard to do when you don’t have all of the discovery. So it’s difficult to set a date,” Campbell said.
Campbell and Rabil said there are 115 discs with interviews and hours of jail calls to listen to as well 294 pages of documents from the Rowan County Department of Social Services and 39 pages from the Cabarrus County Department of Social Services. There are also allegations that go back 10 years and include 12 different residences, they said.
Campbell said they don’t have all the experts they intend to use during the trial lined up. He recommended the attorneys return in February to set a trial date.
Rabil said he has two murder trials scheduled in the spring and summer of 2019 and a few others possibly to be scheduled next year.
“How long do you think it will take for y’all to get up to speed?” Judge Wagoner asked.
“I’ve never seen a trial of this magnitude go to trial in under two years,” Rabil said.
Campbell said he and the other attorneys need to know whether Cook intends to try the Parsonses separately because that would determine their trial strategy.
“We have to fill in all of these gaps that’s not in the discovery before we can even begin to think about trial strategy,” Rabil said.
Rabil said he did a quick Google search under the names of Sandy and Casey Parsons and it yielded 2.5 million hits.
Cook said her office provided documents received through subpoena from the DSS and FBI that were turned over to the attorneys.
She said her office even transcribed jail phone calls and provided them to the attorneys.
Casey Parsons was brought into court clad in a khaki Rowan County jumpsuit. Her husband, Sandy, wearing an orange jumpsuit, was placed in a seat opposite her. The two exchanged a quick look in each other’s direction but never made eye contact during the nearly two-hour hearing.
Wagoner asked to speak with the four attorneys and prosecutor outside the courtroom. When they returned, Wagoner set a Feb. 14 hearing to decide a trial date. She also told the attorneys to not schedule another murder cases in 2019 and to submit in writing a request for other documents from the District Attorney’s Office.
Erica Parsons’ biological mother, Carolyn Parsons, traveled from Virginia to attend the hearing. She was married to Sandy Parsons’ brother, Stevie Parsons.
“I understand there are still things that need to be done,” Carolyn Parsons said after the hearing. “This is just another step closer to where we need to be. I am the first one to say I would be happy for it to be done and over, but I would be the first one to say I want it done right.”
She said she doesn’t want to have to come back in five or 10 years with things still unresolved.
“I want to know that there is justice for Erica. There has been many forms of justice for Erica, and I am grateful for every bit of it,” she said.
When asked about seeing Sandy and Casey in court, Carolyn Parsons said she has no feelings for them.
“My emotions are that I gave one of the most precious gifts that you can give anybody, and that is a child. I trusted them with a precious gift,” she said.
She said if she had the opportunity to go back and do it all over again, she would not leave Erica in their care.
“I would risk bouncing from home to home, place to place because I’d know where she was,” Parsons said.
“Do I think all the right channels were covered when this was going on? No,” she said.
Parsons said she thinks the investigation was thorough. She said she has a lot of confidence in the detectives, particularly investigator Chad Moose and Sheriff Kevin Auten as well as District Attorney Cook.
Contact reporter Shavonne Walker at 704-797-4253.