• 70°

Other voices: Keep politics out of judiciary

Sometimes a bad idea becomes a gift that keeps on giving. So it is with the General Assembly’s attempt to politicize key institutions and its penchant for extreme political gerrymandering of North Carolina.

The gerrymandering has already been slapped down in the courts for its racial biases, and it’s made this state a poster child for a national movement to make redistricting less political. There have even been a few hints that the U.S. Supreme Court may be ready to reconsider its long-held view that redistricting is an inherently political process. We would welcome that decision.

But that has done little to dampen legislative leaders’ drive to make it impossible to dislodge the Republican Party’s iron grip on the state’s government (despite the fact that Republican is the third-ranking voter registration in North Carolina, behind Democrat and unaffiliated).

In recent years, lawmakers have sought to politicize almost every elected position, requiring judges’ political affiliations to appear on ballots and even trying to force judges to become party members by requiring that unaffiliated judges present lengthy petitions to gain ballot access, while party-registered judges need only their own signature to run.

And now, yet another push into politics for our judiciary: a proposal to redraw the judicial and prosecutorial districts across the state. The proposed maps would likely result in some district attorneys losing any chance at re-election. …

Still, we object to judges being forced to run as a member of a party. The very concept of partisanship flies in the face of the principle that in America, justice is supposed to be blind. Judges should be guided by the law and our country’s and states’ constitutions. Judges should check their political beliefs at the courthouse door — or at least try to.

Lawmakers went home before acting on the judicial gerrymandering legislation, but they’re likely to return later in the year to consider it.

We wish they’d consider, instead, the wisdom of N.C. Supreme Court Chief Justice Mark Martin, who told the N.C. Bar Association last month that he favors a ballot question asking voters if judges should even be elected. Martin proposes the possibility of appointing judges instead, subject to the recommendations of an objective review panel appointed by the governor and legislators. The panel would rate judicial nominees’ qualifications.

Martin is one of this state’s most distinguished jurists. He’s also a Republican, but not a blind partisan. It’s clear that he sees the damage politics is causing in our court system.

We’d like to see the General Assembly drop its judicial gerrymandering and instead let the people decide how we choose judges — and whether political affiliation should have anything to do with it. We need fair, unbiased judicial decision-making at every level. And that’s not what our legislative leaders are trying to give us.

— Fayetteville Observer

Comments

BREAKING NEWS

Governor announces phase three of reopening starts Friday

Crime

Blotter: Concord man faces weapons, marijuana charges after traffic stop

Elections

Political sign stealing on the rise in Rowan as campaign season heats up

News

Chaotic first debate: Taunts overpower Trump, Biden visions

Elections

Debate takeaways: An acrid tone from the opening minute

News

Appalachian State student dies following COVID complications

Local

Planning board OKs rezoning for 5-acre property on Mooresville Road

Business

Kannapolis seeking redevelopment proposals for site of old baseball stadium

Elections

Tell us your opinion about the first presidential debate

Education

Kannapolis elementary students will return to full, in-person classes Nov. 2

Coronavirus

10 deaths now reported at Liberty Commons nursing home

Education

Rowan-Salisbury School Board will provide money to help athletics restart

Crime

Blotter: Charlotte teen cited with marijuana possession during traffic stop

Local

Rowan-Salisbury Schools receives $26.3 million grant to accelerate renewal

Local

Child injured after running behind father’s truck

Crime

Police identify man who took them on high-speed chase, crashed into lumber truck

China Grove

Reaper’s Realm owners promise beefed-up security after weekend shooting

Business

Contractor expands local footprint, takes on county’s coronavirus projects

News

Home Improvement: Holiday gifts to spark home improvement ideas

Elections

Political Notebook: Local parties will host watch parties for presidential debate

Crime

China Grove man cited for driving through school field

BREAKING NEWS

October closure hearings set for Faith, Enochville elementary schools

Crime

Police say man gave false name after high speed chase, crashing into lumber truck

Coronavirus

Nearly 400 cases considered currently active in the county