• 77°

Appeals court to reconsider Rowan County prayer case

Court order

Click on the above image for the full court decision.

Click on the above image for the full court decision.

By Josh Bergeron


SALISBURY — Appeals court judges aren’t finished with Rowan County’s prayer lawsuit yet.

On Monday, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals granted a rehearing request from the North Carolina ACLU — representing three Rowan residents in the county’s prayer lawsuit. At issue is whether county commissioners can offer sectarian opening invocations at the start of meetings.

First, in 2015, a federal district court in North Carolina ruled commissioners’ prayer practices were unconstitutional. Then, in September, a three-judge panel in the 4th Circuit Court sided with commissioners by a 2-1 count and overturned the initial ruling. Now, all 15 judges in the 4th Circuit have vacated the court decision in commissioners’ favor and tentatively scheduled a rehearing for Jan. 24 to 26.

The court held a poll of active judges to come to its decision.

“We’re very pleased that the full Fourth Circuit has agreed to review this practice that is clearly out of step with the First Amendment’s protection of religious liberty,” said Chris Brook, legal director of the North Carolina ACLU. “When people attend meetings of their local government, they should not have to worry about being coerced to participate in a sectarian prayer that goes against their beliefs and being discriminated against by local officials when they don’t.”

Reacting to the decision, Commissioners Chairman Greg Edds said only that he was aware the 4th Circuit granted the rehearing request.

Rowan County’s prayer lawsuit represents the first significant case to question public prayer since a 2014 Supreme Court case — Town of Greece v. Galloway. The Greece v. Galloway case has become central in Rowan’s case.

With their decision to grant a rehearing, appeals court judges also moved Rowan’s prayer lawsuit into a relatively small group of cases. Only .3 percent of cases are granted a hearing in front of all 15 judges.

A majority of the 15 judges have been appointed by Democratic presidents — six by President Barack Obama and three by former President Bill Clinton. A Republican appointee, however, was a reason for the ACLU and the three Rowan residents to feel optimistic about a hearing in front of all justices.

In the 4th Circuit’s September dissent, Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson offered a cautionary tale of what might happen if Rowan’s prayer practices were allowed to stand. Wilkinson, appointed by former President Ronald Reagan, has been considered at various points for a U.S. Supreme Court nomination.

“When a seat of government begins to resemble a house of worship, the values of religious observance are put at risk, and the danger of religious division rises accordingly,” Wilkinson wrote in the Rowan County decision. “This, I respectfully suggest, is what is happening here. It cannot be right.”

University of Richmond law professor Carl Tobias said the full court is likely to agree with Wilkinson’s dissent instead of the majority opinion of the three-judge panel. In a previous interview with the Salisbury Post, Tobias said he suspected the court would grant a rehearing.

“I think (Wilkinson’s) treatment of the issues is more persuasive than the majority opinion,” Tobias said.

He also noted Wilkinson’s highly respected stature within the 4th Circuit.

The appointing president, he said, is “too crude an instrument” to be a realistic gauge of the final decision.

“It’s hard to know what the court might do, but I think the sign is the decision to rehear en banc,” Tobias said. “It tells us the court is willing to rehear and maybe more.”

Although the appeals court decision is technically vacated, Tobias said the 15 judges may discuss parts of the majority opinion and dissent before issuing an opinion.

In the district court decision, Judge James A. Beaty wrote that the prayer practices used by Rowan County from 2007 to 2013 — where commissioners offered sectarian, Christian prayers — entangled government with religion and established a pattern of prayers that advanced the Christian faith of elected commissioners at the expense of religions not represented by the board.

In court, Rowan County is being represented by the Texas-based National Center for Life and Liberty, which is not charging the county for its legal services.

Contact reporter Josh Bergeron at 704-797-4246.



Rowan-Salisbury Schools receives $26.3 million grant to accelerate renewal


Child injured after running behind father’s truck


Police identify man who took them on high-speed chase, crashed into lumber truck

China Grove

Reaper’s Realm owners promise beefed-up security after weekend shooting


Contractor expands local footprint, takes on county’s coronavirus projects


Home Improvement: Holiday gifts to spark home improvement ideas


Political Notebook: Local parties will host watch parties for presidential debate


China Grove man cited for driving through school field


October closure hearings set for Faith, Enochville elementary schools


Police say man gave false name after high speed chase, crashing into lumber truck


Nearly 400 cases considered currently active in the county


Rowan-Cabarrus Community College creates free course to help parents tackle virtual learning


New unemployment claims down in August, could indicate positive trend for businesses


Salisbury man faces drug possession charges after overdose call


Police: Man charged after children call 911 from neighbor’s house

Ask Us

Ask Us: Who are people behind sign at City Park playground?


Prison in Salisbury latest site of COVID-19 outbreak


Blotter: Salisbury Man charged with felony assault by strangulation


Trump vows quick Supreme Court vote, Biden urges delay for Nov. 3


New rule may strip pollution protections from popular lakes

East Spencer

East Spencer draws crowd for annual community day


In Rowan’s legislative races, Howard, Warren get off to strongest start in fundraising


From Navy SEAL to Medicare agent, Trent Waller looks to continue serving his community


In 13th Congressional District race, Budd, Huffman differ on government’s role in COVID-19 help