• 61°

Fourth Circuit overturns lower court ruling in Rowan prayer case

Court ruling

Click on the above image to view the full ruling

Click on the above image to view the full ruling

By Josh Bergeron

josh.bergeron@salisburypost.com

SALISBURY — In a 2-1 decision, the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday ruled in favor of Rowan County in a prayer lawsuit filed by the ACLU.

The ruling comes after months of deliberation. Oral arguments were held on Jan. 27.

Previously, North Carolina’s U.S. Middle District Court ruled that Rowan County’s prayer practices at the beginning of each board of commissioners meetings were unconstitutional. At issue in the case is that commissioners themselves gave sectarian prayers at the start of each meeting. The district court specifically found that solemnizing, sectarian prayer during meetings violated the Establishment Clause of the First Ammendment. The 4th Circuit Court reversed the lower court’s decision.

Writing for the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals majority, Judge G. Steven Agee said the district court’s decision is “not supportable.”

“In essence, the district court treated the Supreme Court’s jurisprudential silence on lawmaker-led prayer as conclusively excluding legislators from being permissible prayer-givers to their own legislative bodies,” Agee wrote.

However, Agee wrote that the history and tradition used by the Supreme Court in a critical case for Rowan — Town of Greece vs. Galloway — emphasizes a long-standing tradition of lawmaker-led prayer. In Rowan County’s case, county commissioners give the prayer.

The U.S. Supreme Court did not say anything that could be interpreted as limiting legislative prayer to only clergy, Agee wrote.

Greg Edds, chairman of the Rowan County Board of Commissioners, praised the court’s decision.

“We are very pleased with the decision and think the Court properly decided the matter,” Edds said. “Our attorneys are currently working through the decision and we will know more about it in the coming days.”

In the majority opinion, Agee dismisses every claim made against Rowan County.  Judge Dennis Shedd concurred. Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson wrote a dissenting opinion.

The ACLU, representing three Rowan residents in the case, said the court’s ruling is “out of step with the First Amendment’s protection of religious liberty.”

“Rowan County residents should be able to attend local government meetings without being coerced to participate in a sectarian prayer or worry that the commissioners may discriminate against them if they do not,” said North Carolina ACLU Legal Director Chris Brook. “As Judge Wilkinson wrote in his dissent today, the facts in this case are a ‘conceptual world apart’ from those the U.S. Supreme Court upheld in Greece, New York, and that is why we will seek en banc review.”

By requesting en banc review, the ACLU would be asking the entire U.S. 4th Circuit to hear Rowan’s case instead of only three judges.

In court, attorneys for Rowan County argued that commissioners are the intended target for the prayer. In other words, commissioners are giving a prayer for themselves.

In the 4th Circuit, opinion, Agee said opening prayers “carries special meaning for the thousands of state and local legislators who are citizens themselves.”

“If legislative prayer is intended to allow lawmakers to ‘show who and what they are’ in public form, then it stands to reason that they should be able to lead such prayers for the intended audience: themselves,” Agee wrote.

The majority opinion also considered whether Rowan County’s prayer practices are outside of what’she considered protected prayer.

One factor in the decision was whether prayers were supervised and created by the Board of County Commissioners, instead of being a personal creation. The 4th Circuit court says there’s no evidence that the Board of Commissioners had any role in authoring the prayers.

Prayers never disparage, proselytize or insult, Agee wrote. He also wrote that there’s no evidence to show people who didn’t participate in prayers suffered as a result.

Commissioners who delivered prayers were all Christians, and the 4th Circuit also found that it’s insignificant that only Christian prayers were provided before meetings.

In his dissent, Wilkinson, offered a stark rebuke of Rowan’s prayer practices. He called the prayers a message of exclusion and a potential source of religious division. Rowan’s case is completely separate from the Greece vs. Galloway case, used as a central point in the majority opinion, he said.

“This case is more than a factual wrinkle on Town of Greece vs. Galloway … It is a conceptual world apart,” Wilkinson wrote. “No one disputes that localities enjoy considerable latitude in opening their meetings with invocations and prayers. But the legislative prayer practice here pushes every envelope.”

Wilkinson said that a ruling in favor of Rowan County could affect the nation.

“A ruling for the county bears unfortunate consequences for American pluralism, for a nation whose very penny envisions one out of many, a nation whose surpassing orthodoxy belongs in its constitutional respect for all beliefs and faiths, a nation which enshrined in the First and Fourteenth Amendments the conviction that diversity in all of its dimensions is our abiding strength,” Wilkinson wrote.

Until appeals are finished, county commissioners will  continue using a volunteer chaplain to deliver opening prayers before meetings, according to Edds.

Comments

Crime

Blotter: Man found on church property with litany of drugs

Crime

Man charged in connection to 2019 overdose death

Business

‘It’s our big time’: Salisbury Farmers Market reopens Saturday

Education

Schools capital funding still frozen as RSS sends local budget to county

Business

Shields, Cheerwine Festival receive N.C. Main Street Awards

Kannapolis

Duke University launches kidney disease study in Kannapolis for people of African descent

Education

Horizons Unlimited will hold in-person summer camps

Education

Education briefs: Catawba planning for more in-person activities, free summer school tuition

Coronavirus

County’s full COVID-19 vaccinations top 22,600

High School

High school golf: With Merrell, Mustangs back on top

Local

Spencer investigating rat problem on South Iredell Street

News

Livingstone, Mission House Church to host national ‘Black Voters Matter’ listening session

Education

Shoutouts

Business

Groundbreaking on Pennant Square signals next phase in downtown Kannapolis revitalization

Nation/World

J&J vaccine to remain in limbo while officials seek evidence

Nation/World

Prosecutors: No charges for officer in Capitol riot shooting

Nation/World

Biden to pull US troops from Afghanistan, end ‘forever war’

Nation/World

Former Minnesota cop charged in shooting of Black motorist

Crime

Blotter: April 14

Elections

Former North Carolina Gov. McCrory enters US Senate race

Crime

Salisbury woman arrested in Myrtle Beach for abducting child

Health

County updates health director job description, will advertise for position

High School

High school tennis: East beats Carson, still hopes to share NPC title

Elections

Board of Elections to purchase upgraded voting equipment using federal grant