• 57°

Going to court over tenure

RALEIGH — From Senate leader Phil Berger’s vantage point, the likelihood of a lawsuit probably comes as no surprise.
Berger has been the primary force behind an effort at the North Carolina General Assembly to get rid of teacher tenure in the state.
After two years of talk, the Republican-led legislature approved a measure that drops tenure and its extensive job protections in favor of employment contracts.
Now the state’s largest teacher organization, the N.C. Association of Educators, says it will sue the stop the change.
According to the Associated Press, the lawsuit is likely to argue that forcing existing teachers into the new system violates implied contractual rights to earlier job protections.
Maybe there is something to the argument.
The new plan drawn up by legislators involves a period of transition in which school superintendents identify the top 25 percent of teachers and offer them a $5,000 bonus in exchange for accepting a four-year contract.
Perhaps accepting that bonus eliminates any of those rights.
Principals and school administrators, meanwhile, complain that they have been left with an impossible challenge in identifying the teacher to whom the bonuses will be offered. They say the net result will be that teacher morale is undermined even more.
Berger spokeswoman Amy Auth recently discounted the angst.
“Only in the warped world of education bureaucrats and union leaders could a permanent $5,000 pay raise for top-performing teachers be branded as a bad thing,” Auth said.
Maybe. Or maybe Berger et al needed to look for some buy-in, from somewhere in the public school establishment, even if it meant scaling back the plans.
As I’ve noted previously, the Rockingham County Republican makes a good case that the current tenure system creates roadblocks in getting rid of bad teachers. In 2011-12, just 17 out of 95,000 teachers in the state were fired. Critics of the tenure law also point to cases in which it took months between the beginning and end of the process to dismiss a teacher.
The old tenure law includes requirements for notifications, meetings, hearings and other legal due process obligations. Clearly, it takes a lot of time and money to get rid of bad teachers once they enjoy tenure.
School administrators know that. They can’t be happy with the system as it currently exists. So, they might have been enlisted as allies in the effort to come up with something better, something to streamline the process of getting rid of bad teachers but that avoids undermining morale or hints of political hires and promotions.
Instead, they now have a new system that they don’t like, that is turning them into the bad guys.
Berger and supporters of a contract system of teacher employment might argue that principals and schools superintendents inevitably had to be the bad guys, that putting more accountability into teacher personnel decisions demanded it.
Before we see whether they were right, we may first see whether the process that they created is legal.
Scott Mooneyham covers state government for Capitol Press Association.

Comments

Comments closed.

Kannapolis

Cannon Mills’ whistle sounds again, brings nostalgia with it

Coronavirus

Outbreak at jail annex over; new cases emerge at Kannapolis facility

Elections

In Senate race, Tillis calibrates ties to Trump

News

5 Charlotte officers recommended for dismissal after death in custody

Elections

Trump, Biden hit unlikely battleground state of Minnesota

College

Maui Invitational moving to Asheville during pandemic

News

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg dies at 87

Crime

Blotter: Sept. 19

Coronavirus

Kannapolis brewery linked to eight COVID-19 positives

Elections

Local Democrats call to ‘turn the state blue’ during virtual office reopening

Education

Funding flat, enrollment down slightly for Rowan-Salisbury Schools

Education

Catawba gets high marks in U.S. News and World rankings for fifth year

Business

China Grove soap store sets sights on expansion into Kannapolis

News

Charlotte, UNC game canceled after 49ers place players in quarantine

Crime

Blotter: Sept. 18

Coronavirus

County sees ninth COVID-19 death this week, more than 30 cases reported

BREAKING NEWS

Gov. Cooper announces schools can move K-5 to plan A; school board vote needed locally

Local

Wet weather brings crashes, traffic to standstill on interstate

Crime

Salisbury man victim of Facebook scam, duped out of $2,000

Crime

Two charged after fight outside Salisbury home

Education

Rowan-Salisbury Schools ships out thousands of old devices for refurbishing

Education

Caught in the infodemic: NC school policies frustrated by scientific challenges

East Spencer

East Spencer to hold community day, provide free food, supplies

Education

Shoutouts