• 81°

Concealing judicial discipline

RALEIGH — When any part of a scandal involving a public entity or well-known person becomes public, the details usually come out as well.
Try as they might, by hiring lawyers or hiding behind secretive processes, those involved generally have trouble covering up the particulars once the scent of scandal is in the air.
People talk, reporters snoop and, in the age of the Internet and social media, connecting dots that can reveal the truth has become a lot easier.
If you don’t believe that is the case, you could ask former UNC-Chapel Hill chancellor Holden Thorp how all that dissembling regarding the athletics scandal over there worked out.

This reality of public scandal is one of the reasons that Gov. Pat McCrory should follow the recommendation of the North Carolina Bar Association and veto a bill recently approved by the legislature that would change how the state disciplines its judges.
Under current law, a 13-member panel of mostly judges and lawyers called the Judicial Standards Commission handles much of the discipline involving judges. The commission can dismiss complaints, issue public reprimands or pass along recommendations for more serious disciplinary action to the state Supreme Court.
The legislation would give the Supreme Court more authority, make more of the disciplinary process secretive, and allow the justices on the Supreme Court to oversee complaints made against their fellow justices. Right now, a panel of Court of Appeals judges decides any complaints lodged against a Supreme Court justice.
Legislators aren’t saying much about why they decided to change the process.
If they somehow thought that they might be shielding judges from publicly-exposed complaints that could damage their reputations and public confidence in the courts, they may be doing the opposite.
Just because more of the disciplinary process takes place behind closed doors does not mean that the public won’t learn what has happened.

If, like in Wisconsin, which operates under a similar system, a justice were to be accused of, say, choking another justice, and then other justices recused themselves from considering a complaint so that no quorum could decide the case, would that make the court look better or worse?
Would that instill public confidence in the courts? (That really happened, by the way.)
Or, perhaps the state’s high court dismisses a complaint, only to have the details later batted about in the press in a way that makes the decision appear political. Is that good for the justices and public confidence in them?
Additional public oversight of public officials and public institutions is not only good for the taxpayers who foot the bill and the residents who are supposed to be served equally under the law; that oversight is good for the public officials and public institutions, too.
It provides a means of showing that decisions are not political, that they are fair and equitable.
Changing the system to create less oversight and more conflicts of interest ultimately may harm judges more than anyone else.

Scott Mooneyham writes about state government for Capitol Press Association.

Comments

Comments closed.

Coronavirus

Governor changes course on masks amid worsening trends from delta variant

Coronavirus

Vaccination rules for federal workers toughened

Local

Mayor Alexander joins coalition of NC mayors urging passage of bipartisan infrastructure package

Local

New forklift’s arrival ‘a joyous moment’ for Rowan Helping Ministries

Local

Quotes of the week

East Spencer

Spencer, East Spencer hosting joint National Night Out

Business

Backcountry and Beyond prepares for move to downtown Salisbury

Education

Kannapolis City Schools will ‘strongly recommend,’ not require masks

Business

Ahold Delhaize hopes to add 100 new employees at Salisbury distribution center

Local

Cooler weather on the horizon for Rowan after heat wave

Crime

Blotter: July 29

Local

Downtown residents, business owners say noisy construction is A-OK, sign of progress to come

Business

County unemployment rises in June, positive job growth seen in leisure and hospitality sector

Local

NC poet laureate will speak during historical marker celebration, talks about life, race

Local

Spencer moves back public hearing on longer, staggered terms

Education

High school fire academy lets seniors jump start a service career

News

Country Club of Salisbury unveils renovated clubhouse, plots additional upgrades

David Freeze

David Freeze: Biggest adventure day coming next

Local

South Ellis Street in for improvements because of $100,000 grant for BlockWork

Local

Little League softball: Rowan drops regional final, but moves on

Education

Catawba students, grads make it out to the ballpark for summer of baseball

Education

Education briefs: RSS Teacher of the Year gets Phillip J. Kirk Scholarship

News

North Carolina requiring state health workers to get vaccine

Nation/World

Infrastructure deal: Senate suddenly acts to take up bill