• 32°

Education should be an investment

Is state spending on education an investment or a political payoff? Critics of the North Carolina state budget just approved by Gov. Pat McCrory and the Republican legislature use the term “investment” as lot. But their arguments sound more like cheap politics.
If education spending is an investment, then it can be evaluated with standard criteria such as rate of return per dollar and the opportunity cost of investing that same dollar in something else. When investing in new machinery or technology to boost their productivity, business competitors don’t try to outbid each other in total money spent. On the contrary, they choose only the capital they think will truly pay off in the future — and then they shop for the best bargain. Similarly, you don’t judge the success of your retirement portfolio by how much you invest. You judge the portfolio on the basis of expense ratio and rate of return.
If, however, education spending is really just a means of redistributing dollars from taxpayers to education employees, then its value is directly related to the amount of spending. The more the state taxes and spends on education, the more money public employees receive, and the more they and their family members will be grateful enough to politicians to work for their re-election.
When the 2013-15 budget emerged, Democrats and liberal groups excoriated it for insufficient funding on education. Although the Republicans correctly pointed out General Fund spending on public schools will be $361 million more than last year’s authorized budget, a 5 percent increase, critics argued that the spending increase should have been higher because North Carolina ranks low in per-pupil spending.
If you are investment-minded about education, this argument is unpersuasive. While North Carolina’s spending per public-school student is lower than the national average, that national average is one of the highest levels of school spending in the world. Unfortunately, the average performance of American students is not one of the highest in the world.
In other words, American education is a low-productivity enterprise by international standards. It would be foolish for N.C. leaders to set a goal of being just as bad an investor in education as the rest of the country is. Our goal should be to raise the rate of return on the tax dollars already spent — which will make public education a better investment of tax dollars in the future.
In actual dollars, North Carolina public schools already spend an average of about $9,200 per pupil, including operating and capital costs. That is a large amount of money — and significantly higher than it was a generation ago. If North Carolina were a separate country, that would rank us 10th in the world in education spending.
If you think education should be treated as investment, then you would start with that sizable $9,200 per student and try to figure out how to produce more valuable human capital from it. While both national and international studies find no consistent relationship between per-pupil spending and student outcomes, the available empirical evidence does suggest you can improve learning with institutional reforms such as devolving power to local districts and individual schools, hiring and paying teachers according to performance, and giving parents more ability to choose among competing public and private schools.
These are precisely the measures most state lawmakers voted for this year. They approached North Carolina education as investors armed with good information. Their critics approached North Carolina education as if it were little more than a mechanism for buying votes and placating interest groups.
I side with the investment community on this issue.
John Hood is president of the John Locke Foundation.

Comments

Comments closed.

Local

City officials differ on how, what information should be released regarding viral K-9 officer video

High School

High school basketball: Carson girls are 3A champions

Lifestyle

High school, college sweethearts marry nearly 50 years later

Local

With jury trials set to resume, impact of COVID-19 on process looms

Legion baseball

Book explores life of Pfeiffer baseball coach Joe Ferebee

Education

Rowan-Salisbury Board of Education to receive update on competency-based education

Business

Biz Roundup: Kannapolis expects to see economic, housing growth continue in 2021

Business

A fixture of downtown Salisbury’s shopping scene, Caniche celebrates 15th anniversary this month

Local

Slate of new officers during local GOP convention; Rev. Jenkins becomes new chair

Landis

Landis officials narrow search for new manager to five candidates; expect decision within a month

Lifestyle

Together at last: High school, college sweethearts marry nearly 50 years later

Education

Rowan-Salisbury Schools sorts out transportation logistics in preparation for full-time return to classes

High School

Photo gallery: Carson goes undefeated, wins 3A state championship

Nation/World

Europe staggers as infectious variants power virus surge

Nation/World

Biden, Democrats prevail as Senate OKs $1.9 trillion virus relief bill

Nation/World

Senate Democrats strike deal on jobless aid, move relief bill closer to approval

News

Duke Life Flight pilot may have shut down wrong engine in fatal crash

News

Two NC counties get to participate in satellite internet pilot for students

Local

PETA protesters gather in front of police department

Coronavirus

UPDATED: Eight new COVID-19 deaths, 203 positives reported in county this week

Crime

Sheriff’s office: Two charged after suitcase of marijuana found in Jeep

Crime

Thomasville officer hospitalized after chase that started in Rowan County

Local

Board of elections discusses upgrading voting machines, making precinct changes

News

Lawmakers finalize how state will spend COVID-19 funds