• 57°

No new trial for L.C. Underwood

Staff report
A former Salisbury police officer serving life in prison for murder will not get a new trial, a federal appeals court has ruled.
In a ruling filed Wednesday, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a year-old order by a federal judge to vacate the conviction of Lamont Claxton “L.C.” Underwood in the 1993 kidnapping and murder of Viktor Gunnarsson.
An opinion written to accompany the order, Fourth Circuit judges said the state had “overwhelming evidence” against Underwood and that even if his defense attorneys were ineffective as he argued, that would not have changed the outcome of the case.
The trial drew international attention since Gunnarsson had been accused and cleared in the 1986 assassination of Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme. The Discovery Channel aired a documentary on the investigation after Underwood was convicted.
Underwood, now 59, is serving a life sentence plus 40 years. He is currently in the Marion Correctional Center.
Prosecutors contended that Underwood was jealous of Gunnarsson, seeing him as a romantic rival for Kay Weden, Underwood’s former fiance. Prosecutors contended that Underwood stalked, spied on and harassed Weden before kidnapping Gunnarsson from his home, locking him in the trunk of his 1979 Chevrolet Monte Carlo and driving him to a secluded area 109 miles away along the Blue Ridge Parkway in Watauga County before shooting and killing him with a .22-caliber rifle.
The state also contended that three days later, Underwood shot and killed Weden’s mother, Catherine Miller, at her Westcliffe home off U.S. 70. Underwood was never tried for Miller’s death.
In January 2010, the federal court for the Western District of North Carolina agreed with Underwood’s claim of ineffective counsel in the case and ordered he be given a new trial or released from prison.
Senior Judge Graham Mullen wrote in his opinion that Underwood’s defense employed an “unreasonable strategy” in the 1997 trial.
In opening arguments, defense attorneys told jurors they would present a confession from someone else who claimed to have killed Gunnarsson, as well as witnesses and other evidence that would clear Underwood. The defense put on no evidence.
Graham said it “would be quite difficult to imagine a more illogical, unreasonable strategy” than to promise a jury evidence of a defendant’s innocence then fail to present that evidence or explain why it was not presented.
That “at the very least was irresponsible,” Graham wrote. He went on to say the defense “conduct was deficient and prejudicial” and actually helped prosecutors strengthened a case built on circumstantial evidence.
In a 28-page opinion accompanying the ruling reversing the district court order, the Fourth Circuit Court said Underwood not only had to prove his attorneys were ineffective, but had they not been, the outcome of the trial would have been different.
The state presented “an abundance of evidence” that Underwood had motive for the killing, the court said, namely that he “was a man who would not take ‘no’ for an answer when Weden made crystal clear to him that she no longer desired to continue their relationship.”
The opinion says the state’s evidence showed clear examples of Underwood’s “raging jealousy” of Weden and threats against her and at least one other man she dated after breaking up with Underwood.
The Fourth Circuit court opinion said also that “physical evidence obtained by law enforcement overwhelmingly tied Underwood to Gunnarsson’s murder.” That evidence included an expert’s testimony that electrical tape used to bind Gunnarsson matched tape found at Underwood’s home; that ballistics tests showed the bullets used to kill Gunnarsson could have been fired from a gun Underwood owned; that despite a cleaning of the Monte Carlo, including shampooing the carpet in the trunk, investigators found scratches and a mark resembling a footprint inside the trunk lid; and that hair found in the trunk of Underwood’s car had the same DNA sequencing as a sample of Gunnarsson’s blood.
The Fourth Circuit opinion says Underwood’s attorneys had intended to question investigators about, among other things, another man who had told friends and relatives while drunk that he killed Gunnarsson but later recanted. But the trial judge agreed with prosecutors that defense could not raise those issues during cross examination, but had to bring it up during presentation of their case.
“…Underwood cannot overcome the fact that, when all was said and done, the state’s case against him was iron-clad and overwhelming,” the Fourth Circuit opinion says, “and it is clear to us that there is no reasonable probability that, but for defense counsel’s assumed unprofessional error, the outcome of Underwood’s trial would have been different.”

Comments

Comments closed.

High School

High school football: Hornets overpower South to secure playoff spot

Crime

Jeffrey MacDonald won’t be released despite deteriorating health

Business

Amazon warehouse workers reject union in Alabama

Nation/World

Ex-NFL player’s brain to be probed for trauma-related harm after Rock Hill shootings

Education

Duke University to require COVID vaccinations for fall term

Education

Cooper OKs bill offering K-12 students summer school option

High School

High school football: Record night for Pinckney as East cruises; Carson wins thriller in OT

Nation/World

D-Day survivor, WWII torch bearer Ray Lambert dies at 100

Nation/World

Prince Philip was always defined by role as husband of British queen

BREAKING NEWS

One dead, several injured after head-on collision in China Grove

Crime

Man, woman charged for selling drugs to undercover deputies

Crime

Blotter: Rowan County man charged with indecent liberties with children

Local

Spencer town board gets look at Park Plaza progress

Business

‘Applicant market’: Unemployment rate improving as businesses hire more workers

Local

National, local business leaders praise Salisbury’s initiative to support Black-owned operations

Nation/World

Tillis has prostate cancer surgery

Coronavirus

Adverse reactions surface from Johnson & Johnson vaccine

Nation/World

Expert: Lack of oxygen killed George Floyd, not drugs

Local

Quotes of the week

Nation/World

Biden seeks crackdown on homemade firearms

Nation/World

Victim of former NFL player’s rampage wrote of faith, life’s fragility

News

Wrongly imprisoned man gets $750,000

High School

West falls to Statesville, finishes second in NPC

Education

Middle, high school students head back to classes full time