• 64°

Hood column: ‘Newspeak’ on immigration

By John Hood
RALEIGH ó News journalism should not take sides in political disputes. So the next time you see a newspaper or television station refer to “undocumented workers,” you may properly conclude that it is no longer practicing news journalism.
“Undocumented worker” is the favorite euphemism of many political activists who favor amnesty or other permissive responses to illegal immigration. Their Orwellian goal is to alleviate public concern about illegality and cost by manipulating the English language. It’s a free country, so they get to say whatever they want. But those who claim to report the news dispassionately have no business colluding with such activists to misstate reality with nebulous or ill-fitting terms.
Objectively, the term “undocumented worker” doesn’t work. Not all immigrants are workers. Some are children, disabled, college students, or aged adults, for example. As for documentation, that’s never the real issue at hand. Some citizens or legal residents find themselves “undocumented’ when applying for jobs or services, in the sense that they’ve forgotten or misplaced their birth certificates, Social Security cards, or other items. But many of those who reside in the country illegally or seek illegal, off-the-books employment possess plenty of documentation. It may be fraudulent, but it exists.
The use of the term “undocumented” as a substitute for illegal is absurd. Try applying it to other legal or policy disputes without guffawing.
For example, I happen to be one of those who believe that marijuana should be decriminalized, especially for patients who use it to alleviate pain. I also believe that governments should not regulate occupations such as barbering or auctioneering, and I don’t think that governments should set wages and prices in a marketplace of competent, informed adults. That doesn’t mean I think it would be anything but laughable to demand that reporters call pot an “undocumented therapy,” report that customers who get their hair cut by unlicensed barbers have purchased an “undocumented coiffure,” or refer to business paying workers off-the-books as practitioners of “undocumented capitalism.” These are all illegal acts. I wish they weren’t, but there it is.
As it happens, I am also pro-immigration. I think that, on balance, America benefits from healthy immigration flows and should take pride in its status as a free labor market and a beacon of liberty and opportunity. It is far too difficult for prospective workers to enter the country legally. The strong pull of economic opportunity induces many to disregard the law, with deleterious consequences for themselves and others.
But I recognize that the only way to build public confidence in any future immigration reform is to take their legitimate concerns seriously. The government certainly does have a responsibility to ensure that individuals entering our country are free from communicable disease, have no serious criminal records or intent, and plan to obtain employment to support themselves and their families. So there must be an orderly, legal immigration process. When self-styled “advocates” for immigration use terms such as “undocumented” to describe illegality, they express contempt for the rule of law. It makes the public angry. That’s hardly a step towards immigration reform.
As for journalists, they have no business participating in such a charade. The correct English term to describe those who have entered the United States contrary to law is “illegal alien.” They are illegally residing in the country, which makes them illegal residents. (Sorry to sound so grade-schoolish, but it’s warranted when even college-educated people claim to believe that someone who illegally enters the country is not illegally residing there if he stays.)
And “alien” is a fittingly broader term that “immigrant,” because it includes not just people who come to a country with an honest intent to put down roots (the definition of immigration) but also visitors, criminals, and migrant workers who move back and forth across the border based on seasonal employment needs and family responsibilities back home.
I understand that “alien” now has an E.T.-related snicker factor, so “immigrant” will do as an imperfect but defensible substitute. But “undocumented worker”? Please. Newspeak is not AP style.
– – –
John Hood is president of the John Locke Foundation and publisher of CarolinaJournal.com.

Comments

Comments closed.

Crime

Sheriff’s office: Man takes deputies on chase with stolen moped

Coronavirus

Afternoon, evening COVID-19 vaccination clinic planned Thursday

Crime

Concord man charged with woman’s murder in drive-by shooting

Ask Us

Ask Us: Have city, county elected officials received COVID-19 vaccine?

Local

City gives away nearly 100 trees during ‘We Dig Salisbury’ event

Local

Political Notebook: Bitzer expects most ‘Trump-like’ candidate to be favorite in state’s Senate race

Crime

Blotter: Concord man arrested in Rowan for indecent liberties with children

Coronavirus

Half of US adults have received at least one COVID-19 shot

Nation/World

Police: FedEx shooter legally bought guns used in shooting

News

Hester Ford, oldest living American, dies at 115 … or 116?

Local

Size of pipeline spill again underestimated in North Carolina

BREAKING NEWS

Kannapolis Police searching for suspect who fled scene of homicide

Education

RSS superintendent talks district’s future, strategic plan survey

News

Complaints and fines pile up against unpermitted landfill in southwest Rowan County

College

Catawba baseball: Crowd comes out to say goodbye to Newman Park

Lifestyle

History is a great teacher: Farming has helped shape Rowan County

Business

‘A safe place for them’: Timeless Wigs and Marvelous Things celebrates fifth anniversary

China Grove

County will hear request for more tree houses, hobbit-style homes in China Grove

Coronavirus

Livingstone College partners with Health Department to administer 500 Pfizer vaccinations

Education

‘Elite and it shows’: Staff at Partners in Learning at Novant celebrate news of national accreditation

Business

Biz Roundup: Food Lion earns Energy Star award for 20th consecutive year

Columns

Ester Marsh: What body type are you?

Nation/World

The queen says goodbye to Philip, continues her reign alone

Nation/World

Worldwide COVID-19 death toll tops a staggering 3 million