• 77°

The case for practicality

“Throughout our schools and communities, the American people have a very strong sense that the No Child Left Behind Act is not fair, not flexible and is not funded. And they are not wrong.”
ó Rep. George Miller
D-California
The Rowan-Salisbury Schools are simultaneously rejoicing and bemoaning. On the positive side, three schools labeled with “corrective action” or “school improvement” under No Child Left Behind guidelines a year ago reversed the trend this year and made adequate yearly progress ó the holy grail of federal education accountability.
But several other schools did not make that level of progress on reading and math standards, and three more schools now bear the scarlet letter of “school improvement.”
Meanwhile, debate on Capitol Hill throws into question the validity of No Child Left Behind to begin with, and the state is doing away with school improvement teams like the one the Rowan-Salisbury schools so urgently mustered up for this spring. So we have local educators shaping their classroom instruction ó and being considered successful or unsuccessful ó based solely on testing standards that are themselves under scrutiny.
This is beginning to feel like a Gordian Knot, the mythical rope tied so thickly and tightly that the only way out was to slice it with a sword. Before anyone axes No Child Left Behind, though, it deserves a chance to adjust and prove its worth.
Regardless of changes that may be coming, the staffs and students at the schools that improved their status ó China Grove, Granite Quarry and North Rowan elementaries ó deserve kudos for reaching all targets for all student subgroups, a very demanding standard. So do three other schools that reached all targets: Cleveland, Enochville and Faith. As it is now, No Child Left Behind is unforgiving; a school that misses one of its targets gets the same label as one that misses all of them. This is one of the faults lawmakers have vowed to fix.
Meanwhile, the public must recognize the impact No Child Left Behind has had on the public schools. Teachers and administrators have been put under great pressure to make all children succeed, which has caused great stress. In the long run, that push can be good for students ó especially disadvantaged or handicapped children who might not have been expected to succeed in the past ó as long as they themselves don’t get too stressed out. In some cases, teachers say, it is virtually impossible to meet targets.
No Child has helped the system in a backhanded way. Rowan-Salisbury’s mediocre showing last year put a spotlight on problems that might have remained in the shadows: teachers not following the state’s standard course of study, for example, and other signs of a decentralized system that imposed few standards. Under Dr. Judy Grissom’s leadership, that is changing. Given time and resources, the system as a whole should be able to improve its showing under No Child Left Behind.
The trick for Congress is making the federal program’s standards fairer and more flexible without rendering it meaningless. Fairer should not be weaker. Public schools need a realistic model, not an escape hatch. Ideally, No Child would make educators continue to strive for higher goals without feeling they’ve been asked to do the impossible.

Comments

Comments closed.

Crime

Chase from Mooresville ends with crash at Rowan Mill Road; two charged

Kannapolis

Dearmons gift two public art sculptures to city of Kannapolis

Crime

Blotter: Woman’s camper stolen from side of I-85

Local

Local scouts sweep NC American Legion awards

Business

As demand lessens slightly, local homebuilders work through challenges to deliver dwellings

Local

Commissioners name Newberry Hall House county’s newest historic landmark

News

Senate budget uses NC revenue boon on more tax cuts, capital

College

Livingstone College alumna Quanera Hayes makes U.S. Olympic Team after first-place finish in 400-meter race

Crime

Blotter: June 21

Ask Us

Ask Us: What is status of ‘speed table’ on Charles Street in Spencer?

Local

East Rowan High graduate killed in motorcycle crash

Local

Political Notebook: Gov. Cooper vetoes Ford-backed bill allowing firearms at churches that are also schools

Crime

Blotter: June 20

News

Body of fourth tuber, age 7, found in North Carolina river

Nation/World

8 kids in youth van among the 13 lives lost to Claudette

Local

Hundreds turn out for annual Juneteenth celebration on newest federal holiday

Local

Between local champions and an upcoming state tournament, pickleball putting Salisbury on map

Business

Business leaders hope to draw big crowd for job fair at West End Plaza

News

Officers cleared in Mooresville shooting

Business

From firefighter to photographer, Brianna Mitschele is ready to capture more moments in downtown Salisbury

News

25 years later, runners reflect on Olympic torch’s trip through Rowan

News

Commissioners to consider designating Newberry Hall House as county historic landmark

Farm & Garden

51st annual Old Southeast Threshers’ Reunion set for July 1-5

Business

Biz Roundup: St. Luke’s Episcopal Church Foundation awards grants from Salisbury to Jerusalem