• 88°

In response: No 'sour note' on Toyota, but some real concerns

By Tina Hall

For the Salisbury Post

I am responding to the Jan. 18 editorial written by the Salisbury Post involving the Toyota tax incentive deal approved at the last County Commission meeting. The editorial worried me because it gave readers the impression that the commissioners were supposed to rubber stamp the tax incentive proposal with an automatic yes vote.

Commissioner Jim Sides and I were accused in the editorial of injecting a “sour note” by asking questions and then voting against the tax incentive. Disappointingly, the Post failed its readers by giving an incomplete picture of this important issue.

At Tuesday’s meeting, I pointed out that the Economic Development Commission had not provided a prospectus showing possible gains to Rowan County if Toyota employees were to locate here. Of the 40 projected hires, most if not all come from outside of Rowan County. No impact study has been given to commissioners as required by our Investment Grant Program. Commissioners evaluate these grants using the guidelines as stated in our published program.

Toyota has yet to provide definitive information on additional phases of development for the Cline site or provide any type of guarantee that they will stay in Rowan County after the five-year incentive expires. In other words, commissioners were given nothing in writing for such a substantial business deal involving citizen tax dollars. In my opinion, these are legitimate concerns — not sour notes.

Further, I stated my concerns about Rowan’s unemployment rate being high compared to surrounding counties. Information was given at the EDC retreat that showed a sharp increase in unemployment since June. I’m concerned. Also, I have learned that one of Rowan’s largest employers is planning to reduce its workforce substantially. Again, I’m concerned. According to our Investment Grant Program, jobs are a legitimate consideration for approval of tax incentive money, as are other areas. Did the Post editorial board check factors other than tax-base enhancement that commissioners might have considered from the county’s list of guidelines? Remember, we’re talking guidelines here — not county policy, as described in the Post editorial.

Bottom line, should we be putting all of our tax incentive eggs in one basket — one that fails to create jobs for Rowan citizens? Right or wrong — these areas (as stated that night) factored into my decision to deny the tax incentive. I believe that Toyota intends to locate here primarily because it suits their needs at this point in time. Toyota is investing $22 million. In my opinion, the $519,000 tax incentive is the icing — not the cake.

The Salisbury Post demands fair and open government, as it should. Its readers deserve more than one side of the issue.

* * *

Tina Hall is a member of the Rowan County Board of Commissioners.


Comments closed.

Ask Us

Ask Us: When will front entrance to courthouse reopen?


As COVID-19 cases wane, vaccine-lagging areas still at risk


Blotter: Man faces litany of charges for fleeing sheriff’s deputies

Granite Quarry

‘Race to the Dan’ brings Revolutionary War back to Rowan


‘Unity in the Community’ event brings together Salisbury Police, NAACP


One killed, two others shot on South Jackson Street in Salisbury


State examining Davidson County emergency alert received in Rowan, other counties


Cleveland Rodeo packs house for 10th year


Salisbury’s Jacques Belliveau talks mental health, filming during premiere of ‘Reggie: A Millennial Depression Comedy’


Sen. Ford backs new set of election-related bills


Downtown Salisbury bullish on potential for more residential space


Biz Roundup: Wine about Winter set for June 18


Local artists draw in adventurous travelers with eclectic Airbnb rental downtown


Commissioners discussing reviving joint capital project committee with school board


Beech-Nut Stage One cereal recalled


‘All Critters Big and Small’ program coming to library


Area Sports Briefs: Former A.L. Brown standout Cambrea Sturgis wins two sprint events


RSS administration to recommend return to five-day school week


Baseball notebook: Wingate wins national championship; high schools set sights on playoffs


Gene Seaford gets fifth career ace at age 90


Livingstone seeking nominees for inaugural ‘Forty Under 40’ Society


‘Stopping that cycle’: Edman named director of Prevent Child Abuse Rowan


Biden urges G-7 leaders to call out and compete with China


Rash of mass shootings stirs US fears heading into summer