• 52°

Column: Debate on hog-farm moratorium will get messier

By Scott Mooneyham

Capitol Press Association

RALEIGH — When it comes to North Carolina’s moratorium on industrial-style hog farms, this year could bear a striking resemblance to “Alice in Wonderland.”

Down is up. Up is down. Hog farmers want it. Environmentalist doan’t.

The General Assembly first approved the moratorium, which applies to new farms with more than 250 hogs, in 1997. The moratorium came in response to a series of hog waste spills, including a massive one in the New River in Onslow County, as industrial-style hog farming took off in the state.

Environmental groups partied in the streets. The powerful hog barons shook their fists toward Raleigh.

Then, a funny thing happened. The hog farmers and their integrator bosses suddenly realized that this moratorium thing wasn’t so bad after all.

If you were already in the business, a ban on new farms meant no new competition.

Since the initial ban, the moratorium has been extended three times, the last in 2003 for four additional years. The 2003 extension produced all the drama of a repeat of “Leave It to Beaver.”

After all, the industry and environmentalists were on the same side of the issue.

Don’t look for a repeat in 2007.

With the moratorium scheduled to end later this year, many of the state’s environmental lobbying groups seem bent on allowing the moratorium to drop. In its place, they want a permanent ban on any new open-air hog lagoons and a requirement that any new farms use cleaner technology to treat hog waste.

Dan Whittle, a lawyer with the North Carolina offices of Environmental Defense, says he also expects a push to establish a deadline for the conversion of existing hog lagoons to cleaner alternatives.

Then-Attorney General Mike Easley did call for “a strict timetable” to eliminate lagoons seven years ago when he negotiated a deal with Smithfield Foods and Premium Standard Farms to begin studying alternatives.

Obviously, the big pork processors, citing study findings that alternatives could cost as much as five times more than the current lagoon-spray field systems, aren’t likely to willingly go along with such a timetable.

A more interesting issue to watch will be the fight over a moratorium extension verses a requirement for any new hog farms to use new technology.

While replacing existing lagoons may be cost prohibitive, the environmental crowd argues that using newer technology rather than digging new lagoons is not.

As for imposing a deadline for phase-out of lagoons, that talk may be a negotiating position meant to get legislators to seriously consider a proposal to provide grant money for farmers who want to voluntarily switch to alternative waste treatment.

A bill to provide $10 million for such conversions went nowhere last year, even though a number of farmers backed the proposal.

The long-term answers won’t all come in 2007, but the year may well mark a start rather than a continuation of the decade-long pause that has been the moratorium.

* * *

Scott Mooneyham is a columnist for Capitol Press Association.


Comments closed.


Three deaths, 29 new COVID-19 positives reported


Blotter: Bullet holes found in woman’s Park Avenue apartment


Man faces assault charges for domestic incident

High School

Photo gallery: Carson girls win West Regional, headed to state championship

High School

High school basketball: Carson girls headed to state championship game


Commissioners set date for public hearing on potential solar energy system rule changes


Two of Rep. Sasser’s bills successfully pass through Health Committee


Rep. Warren’s measure to allow removal of public notices from newspapers put on back burner

China Grove

China Grove Town Council weighs future of previously rejected housing development


Salisbury City Council hears public comments, receives presentation on Main Street reconfiguration


Blotter: Man charged with felony drug offenses


California crash kills 13 of 25 people crammed into SUV


Biden vows enough vaccines by end of May


State to vaccinate medically vulnerable starting March 24


One new death, 20 new COVID-19 positives reported in Rowan


Kannapolis man dies in moped crash


Salisbury Police chief addresses K-9 video, says officer separated from animal


Rowan Rescue Squad sets record straight on fundraising typo


City approves DOT agreement, Salisbury Station project could begin next year


County plans to use vulture effigy, enforce violations to remedy animal carcass feeding problem


Two weeks after ending enhanced protocols, Catawba has no COVID-19 cases


Council to hear revised version of Downtown Main Street Plan


Veto override of NC school reopening bill fails in Senate


Political Notebook: Majority of likely voters, local legislators support school reopening bill