• 73°

Local legislators support limiting damages in nuissance lawsuits

By Josh Bergeron


SALISBURY — At least three of Rowan County’s four state legislators support a controversial proposal to limit financial damages in lawsuits involving agriculture or forestry operations.

State Reps. Carl Ford, R-China Grove, and Harry Warren, R-Salisbury, as well as Sen. Andrew Brock, R-Mocksville, have either voted for or sponsored a bill that would cap the amount of money that could be awarded in lawsuits in which plaintiffs allege that agriculture or forestry operations cause a nuisance for neighbors.

A version of the bill was introduced in the state House on March 23. It passed the House on Monday. A version was also introduced in March, but it hasn’t advanced out of the chamber.

Brock co-sponsored a version of the proposal in the Senate. When asked about his support, Brock said people should expect that rural areas will have farms nearby.

“Many times, people will move into an area, and they don’t like the farm, so then they file a lawsuit,” Brock said. “That would be kind of like saying someone moves into downtown Salisbury and saying, ‘I don’t like street noise.’ In rural areas, you’re going to have farming activity.”

He said lawsuits cause farmers to spend more time in the courtroom than on the farm.

The proposal has attracted opposition for more than general nuisance lawsuits against farms. A number of lawsuits are pending against a division of Smithfield Foods because of claims about flies and the smell of animal waste. An initial version of the bill would have affected ongoing lawsuits.

Before a version of the proposal — House Bill 467 — moved through the state House on Monday, an amendment was passed to exclude pending lawsuits. Ford and Warren both voted for the amendment.

“Without the amendment, there was great concern that it would have been unconstitutional by affecting pending cases,” Warren said. “Some of these (lawsuits) reach back as far as five years.”

Warren voted against House Bill 467 when it didn’t have the amendment on existing cases. Ford supported the bill without the amendment.

Brock said he supports the amendment, which is already included in the Senate version.

“We’re talking about changing things midstream, and I don’t like to interfere with the court process,” he said.

However, Brock also said high financial awards associated with agriculture lawsuits can drive up food prices.

Ford said he supports the bill as amended mostly because of its effect on property rights.

“Everybody says, ‘I don’t want you telling me what to do with my land,’ but they all want to tell other people what to do with their land,” Ford said.

He said House Bill 467 resulted in the most constituent feedback of any recent proposal in the legislature, including the controversial House Bill 2.

“Obviously, you’ve got lots of farmers in Cabarrus and Rowan in the part I represent,” Ford said. “Most of them were saying, ‘Protect our farms and protect our property rights.’”

House Bill 467, as amended, now sits in the Senate Committee on Rules and Operations. The similar bill, co-sponsored by Brock, is before the Senate Agriculture Committee.

Because it has already passed through one chamber, it’s possible the state Senate will vote on House Bill 467 rather than the Senate version.

Contact reporter Josh Bergeron at 704-797-4246.


High School

High school football: Hornets overpower South to secure playoff spot


Jeffrey MacDonald won’t be released despite deteriorating health


Amazon warehouse workers reject union in Alabama


Ex-NFL player’s brain to be probed for trauma-related harm after Rock Hill shootings


Duke University to require COVID vaccinations for fall term


Cooper OKs bill offering K-12 students summer school option

High School

High school football: Record night for Pinckney as East cruises; Carson wins thriller in OT


D-Day survivor, WWII torch bearer Ray Lambert dies at 100


Prince Philip was always defined by role as husband of British queen


One dead, several injured after head-on collision in China Grove


Man, woman charged for selling drugs to undercover deputies


Blotter: Rowan County man charged with indecent liberties with children


Spencer town board gets look at Park Plaza progress


‘Applicant market’: Unemployment rate improving as businesses hire more workers


National, local business leaders praise Salisbury’s initiative to support Black-owned operations


Tillis has prostate cancer surgery


Adverse reactions surface from Johnson & Johnson vaccine


Expert: Lack of oxygen killed George Floyd, not drugs


Quotes of the week


Biden seeks crackdown on homemade firearms


Victim of former NFL player’s rampage wrote of faith, life’s fragility


Wrongly imprisoned man gets $750,000

High School

West falls to Statesville, finishes second in NPC


Middle, high school students head back to classes full time