• 73°

Prayer lawsuit attorneys argue in federal appeals court

By Josh Bergeron 


RICHMOND, Va. — Attorneys on both sides of Rowan County’s prayer lawsuit on Wednesday presented oral arguments to a three-judge panel in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.

The focus of Rowan’s prayer lawsuit is the constitutionality of County Commissioners’ prayer practices at the start of meetings. The case first began in 2013 in North Carolina’s Middle District Court, where the prayer practices were ruled unconstitutional. Commissioners voted to appeal the ruling in June 2015.

Rowan County on Wednesday was represented in federal appeals court by attorneys associated with Texas-based National Center for Life and Liberty. Plaintiffs Nan Lund, Robert Voelker and Lisa Montag-Siegel were represented in court by the American Civil Liberties Union.

Rowan County’s attorneys went first in oral arguments. They were given an initial 15 minutes to address complaints by the plaintiffs. Later they received additional time for a rebuttal.

Allyson Ho, an attorney for Rowan, focused part of her argument on whether the identity of a prayer giver — County Commissioners in this case — mattered. Ho said identity didn’t matter.

The identity of the prayer giver has gained greater significance in the ACLU’s arguments following Town of Greece vs. Galloway, a Supreme Court case permitting volunteer chaplains to give an opening invocation.

Ho also emphasized the long-standing tradition of prayer before legislative meetings.

ACLU North Carolina Legal Director Christopher Brook, representing the plaintiffs, was given about 30 minutes for oral arguments. A major point in Brook’s argument focused on whether commissioners directed members of the public to participate. He cited a few examples of past prayers that appeared to be for the benefit of and directed at members of the public instead of only county commissioners. Brook called commissioners’ prayers coercive because they were, at times, directed at members of the public.

During oral arguments, Ho told judges 100 percent of Rowan County Commissioners’ prayers from 2007 to 2013 were overtly Christian. U.S. Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson repeatedly said he was concerned about the combination of legislators giving every prayer with 100 percent of prayers being Christian.

The other two judges — G. Steven Agee and Dennis Shedd — didn’t overtly discuss how they felt about issues in the case.

Judges didn’t rule on the case during Wednesday’s day in court. A ruling, however, is the most likely next step in the case. It’s unclear when a ruling might be issued.

Plaintiffs Nan Lund and Robert Voelker attended Wednesday’s oral arguments. County Commissioners Chairman Greg Edds also attended.

Edds didn’t express an opinion on the details of Wednesday’s oral arguments, but said he thought attorneys representing Rowan County did well. Edds said judges had also clearly studied the case extensively.

A full story will appear in Thursday’s Salisbury Post.




Salisbury man faces drug possession charges after overdose call


Police: Man charged after children call 911 from neighbor’s house

Ask Us

Ask Us: Who are people behind sign at City Park playground?


Prison in Salisbury latest site of COVID-19 outbreak


Blotter: Salisbury Man charged with felony assault by strangulation


Trump vows quick Supreme Court vote, Biden urges delay for Nov. 3


New rule may strip pollution protections from popular lakes

East Spencer

East Spencer draws crowd for annual community day


In Rowan’s legislative races, Howard, Warren get off to strongest start in fundraising


From Navy SEAL to Medicare agent, Trent Waller looks to continue serving his community


In 13th Congressional District race, Budd, Huffman differ on government’s role in COVID-19 help


Rowan County Telecommunications joins new state digital 911 system


School board will consider scheduling public hearings for Faith, Enochville closures


Biz Roundup: Food Lion makes donation to support racial equality and justice


Republicans rally supporters at Saturday lunch


Budd holds wide lead over Huffman in fundraising, cash on hand


UPDATED: 1 shot, 5 in custody after shooting at haunted house that attracted 1,000 visitors


Trump picks conservative Amy Coney Barrett to fill Supreme Court seat


Deadly September propels Rowan County to 100 deaths from COVID-19


Highway Patrol charges man in hit-and-run after finding vehicle hidden in woods


NC elections board, Republicans at odds over absentee ballot rule changes


Voters struggling with witness rules in early voting


Trump expected to announce conservative Amy Coney Barrett for Supreme Court


County reports COVID-19 percent positive rate of 8%