• 66°

Paul Stam: Death penalty dispute

Paul Stam

State Rep. Paul Stam of Apex is speaker pro tem of the N.C. House of Representatives.

State Rep. Paul Stam of Apex is speaker pro tem of the N.C. House of Representatives.

By Paul Stam

Special to the Post

The writer is responding to a recent column about the death penalty:

Mr. Patrick Gannon repeats familiar arguments against the death penalty for first-degree murder:

1. Claim: Opposition to abortion logically requires opposition to the death penalty.

Refutation: It is difficult to imagine a sin, much less a crime, which any unborn child has committed. But those on death row for first degree murder have been convicted beyond a reasonable doubt by a jury and have had their cases reviewed by at least 47 judges looking for errors of law or fact over the course of 10 to 25 years. The unborn child has had zero representation and has been charged with nothing.

2. Claim: The death penalty is inefficient and expensive.

Refutation: Much of the expense results from obstruction by opponents of the death penalty.

3. Claim: Many people have been exonerated from death row.

Refutation: In the modern era there have been 44 executions in North Carolina, all convicted of first-degree murder. Not a single one of them had any colorable claim to innocence.

4. Claim: There is no clear consistent evidence that the death penalty deters crimes.

Refutations: There are dozens of peer reviewed academic studies showing clear deterrent effect for a death penalty for murder that is actually applied.

In North Carolina no one has been executed for first degree murder since 2006. There is little deterrent value in a penalty that is never applied. The studies vary, but a conservative estimate is that 25 innocent lives are saved by each execution of a guilty first degree murderer in a state that actually applies the death penalty.

5. Claim: Criminals deserve a long time to reflect and repent so that God can redeem them.

Refutation: It takes 10 to 25 years for a death sentence to be carried out. Whether a person is more likely to repent and be redeemed when facing life in prison that goes on indefinitely, more likely to repent and be redeemed when facing an imminent execution is ultimately unknowable. Intuitively I would think the latter is more likely.

The death sentence for first-degree murder carried out after thorough review for innocence respects human life for victims in a way that a sentence of life in prison can never match.

The innocent lives lost due to the lack of a sufficient deterrent for first-degree murder cry out for justice.

Rep. Paul Stam of Apex is speaker pro tem of the N.C. House.



Man charged for stowing away on Norfolk Southern train, impeding railroad operations


Group will protest treatment of Georgia woman during 2019 traffic stop


Man overdoses at Piedmont Correctional Institute


Sheriff’s Office: Two men escape from jail, found in bushes on Fulton Street

Ask Us

Ask Us: When will North Martin Luther King Jr. Avenue be resurfaced?


Political Notebook: Rowan’s lawmakers pass 140 bills into the opposite chamber before deadline


Police chief to present use of force policy; city manager to present 2021-22 budget


Blotter: Rockwell man arrested on charges of felony larceny, possession of stolen vehicle


CDC director says mask turnaround based solely on science


Catawba College hosts three in-person commencement ceremonies


With high case loads causing numerous staff departures, Child Protective Services seeks more positions


Livingstone College graduates celebrate ‘crossing the finish line’ during commencement celebration


Rowan sees 4 new COVID-19 deaths as mask mandate lifted, vaccines administered continue decline


Spencer is latest town updating its development ordinance


Salisbury native Kristy Woodson Harvey makes NY Times bestseller list


Board of Commissioners will convene for third time in May


Biz Roundup: Salisbury, Kannapolis among recipients of Region of Excellence Awards


Cheerleading team competes at Disney


Salisbury High to celebrate football, swimming champions with parade

High School

High school girls soccer: Isley, Webb lead all-county team


Spencer awarded $10,000 to develop trails at Stanback Forest


‘Tails and Tales’ coming to library this summer


Public Records: March Deeds


Salisbury Symphony’s ‘Return to the Concert Hall’ available May 24-31