| Salisburys
Lion is hungry again, but after 42 years of
strictly Southern cuisine, its hoping to
spice up its stock with a dish of Thai.
Food
Lion executives outlined plans to invest $10
million into a 10-store chain of grocery stores
in Bangkok, Thailand, during the companys
annual shareholders meeting Thursday morning at
Catawba College.
Food
Lions new team of top executives tried to
convince stockholders that despite
stellar financial
performance this year record sales of
$10.2 billion and record earnings of $273 million
the value of Food Lion stock wont
catch up with other chains until large-scale
institutional investors
view Food Lion as an aggressive firm bent on
acquisitions.
Bill
McCanless, who last month replaced Tom Smith as
Food Lion CEO, recognized the frustration
stockholders must feel when faced with sparkling
finances but stagnant stock prices.
I
know how you feel: Thats all well and good,
but when is the stock going up?
McCanless said in the only unprepared part of his
speech.
Robert
Ketner, son of Food Lion co-founder Ralph Ketner,
noted in the meeting that since 1988, the value
of Food Lion stock has risen 40 percent a
paltry amount compared to a fourfold increase in
the value of Winn-Dixies stock and a
750-percent appreciation of Albertsons
stock.
According
to McCanless and Pierre Beckers, chairman of the
Food Lion board of directors, investing $10
million into Thailand may help break the relative
poor performance of Food Lion stock that has
befuddled the company under Smiths reign as
president and CEO.
Smith
retired suddenly in April as Food Lion president,
CEO and chairman of the board.
McCanless
stressed at the meeting that he wasnt
appointed as CEO to turn this company
around. Tom Smith ran this company very
well.
Indeed,
much of the new leaderships plans revolve
around business practices championed by Smith.
For instance, McCanless assured stockholders
there is room for organic
growth in the companys core
market in the Southeast through the
ink blot approach to
expansion, which entails adding stores in areas
that can be served by Food Lions existing
distribution network.
Joe
Hall, Food Lion chief operating officer, outlined
other new initiatives for the companys
1,141 stores, including self-checkout lanes,
in-store banks and The Medicine Shoppe
pharmacies.
Though
some local stockholders at the meeting applauded
McCanless appointment as new CEO and
Beckers election as chairman of the board,
others worried that the new management team
and its overseas plans may signal
even tighter control of the corporation by its
foreign stockholders.
Beckers
also serves as CEO of Delhaize, a Belgian company
specializing in international retail. For more
than 20 years, Delhaize has owned the largest
single block of Food Lion stock. The company now
depends on Food Lion for about 70 percent of its
profits.
As the
majority stockholder, Delhaize enjoys an
insurmountable advantage in picking who serves on
the Food Lion board of directors. With the
election Thursday, Delhaize officials hold four
of the 10 board seats.
Some
Salisbury stockholders remain uneasy about
Delhaize influence over Food Lions
plans, and said so at the meeting.
During
a question-and-answer session, one man stood and
asked McCanless if it were possible for
individual shareholders to elect a board member
without the support of Delhaize. McCanless
answered, Its been that way for
20 years. Its nothing new.
The man
responded: Then why spend the money
to tabulate the votes?
Ralph
Ketner, Food Lion co-founder and one of its
largest individual stockholders, wrote a letter
to McCanless earlier this week criticizing the
Thailand proposal and complaining of
Delhaizes influence in electing Food Lion
board members.
In the
letter, Ketner asked if Food Lion
management (has) so quickly forgotten its Texas
fiasco. Food Lion invested almost
$300 million in the late 80s and early
90s in an unsuccessful attempt to break
into the Southwest market.
In an
interview before the shareholders meeting,
McCanless said he believes Texas and Thailand are
two totally different
situations.
First
of all, in the Thai situation, Delhaize has
already been there for several years,
he said. They studied the market.
They came up with a concept that fits well with
the market. Its been running now for
several years, and theyre beginning to have
name recognition.
Beckers
agreed that the two situations are much
different. In Texas, you had
competition that was fairly structured and
mature, he said. Now in
Thailand with 60 million people, you have just a
few hundred supermarkets and that includes some
fairly small stores, self service as well. So the
opportunity is there.
At the
meeting, Beckers said, We want Food
Lion to be a part of the consolidation in the
U.S. retail sector, and we are actively looking
for opportunities that would give Food Lion new
areas of development in the future. If a
worthwhile acquisition target becomes available,
Delhaize will consider providing additional
financial support, if needed to make the deal
happen.
Ketner
was the last shareholder to speak during
Thursdays meeting. He asked McCanless if he
planned to answer his questions in writing.
McCanless
said yes, and Ketner suggested he do so in an
open letter to the Salisbury Post and Charlotte
Observer.
McCanless
did not waiver in his belief that Delhaize offers
Food Lion valuable expertise in the global
marketplace, and that growth outside the U.S. is
the best way to break into new markets where
competition is less severe.
Delhaize
owns grocery stores in Belgium, France, the Czech
Republic, Greece and various Asian countries. The
firm bought two Bel-Thai
stores in Bangkok a few years ago and has since
expanded to 10 stores. Delhaize approached Food
Lion about the project after a partner in
Thailand backed out of the project, according to
Beckers.
The six
members of the Food Lion board of directors not
directly affiliated with Delhaize must approve
the $10 million investment, which would provide
Food Lion with 51-percent ownership of the chain.
These members, elected Thursday, are: McCanless;
Margaret Kluttz, former Salisbury mayor and N.C.
Board of Transportation member; Joseph Hall Jr.,
Food Lion chief operating officer; Dr. Bernard
Franklin, president of St. Augustine College in
Raleigh; William Ferguson, director of Snow
Aviation International; and Dr. Jacqueline
Collamore, a Chevy Chase, Md., corporate
consultant. EST
|