|
Wednesday, June 18, 2008 3:00 AM
E-mail to a friend
By Mark Wineka
mwineka@salisburypost.com
Salisbury Fire Chief Bob Parnell said Tuesday a 4- to 6-inch gash in the hose manned by four firefighters, including Victor Isler and Justin Monroe, led to their losing water as they fought the Salisbury Millwork fire March 7.
The cut hose represents what the Fire Department considers "mechanical damage" and why the hose team, led by Capt. Rick Barkley, lost water pressure on their end while they were in the woodworking plant.
A Rapid Intervention Team from Locke Fire Department was able to reach Barkley inside and get him to safety. Barkley suffered first- and second-degree burns.
Another member of the hose team, Brian Roberts, made it out of the building, but Isler and Monroe died from heat exposure.
Parnell said investigators believe the fire hose was cut when it was dragged across a sharp object somewhere inside the plant, which was destroyed in the $2 million fire.
The Fire Department knows about the gash in the hose because Barkley saw it and radioed in about the dead line.
Parnell said the cut led to the loss of water at the end of the hose, while the front end continued to have pressure.
Last week, narratives accompanying final autopsy reports for Isler and Monroe mentioned that the hose the men were manning that day "burned in two."
Parnell indicated that the autopsy narrative about the hose wasn't meant to reflect anything official and that his final report will speak to the gash and not the hose's being burned as the reason the team lost water.
Fire burned the hose later.
Barkley followed the hose out to a point where exhaustion took over and he couldn't go any farther. It's there that the Rapid Intervention Team was able to find him.
In honor of Isler and Monroe Tuesday, the Firehouse Subs Public Safety Foundation donated two thermal imaging cameras worth $22,000 total. One will go to the Salisbury Fire Department; the other to Miller's Ferry Fire Department, where Monroe also served as a volunteer.
Parnell and Miller's Ferry Fire Chief Bobby Fox, who also serves as a captain with Salisbury, accepted the cameras at Tuesday's City Council meeting.
Three thermal imaging cameras — two belonging to Salisbury and one of Locke's — were destroyed in the Salisbury Millwork fire.
Parnell said each of the four Quint teams and Rescue 1 used thermal imaging cameras in the Salisbury Millwork fire.
Capt. David Morris of the Salisbury Fire Department said the handheld MSA 5200 cameras, often carried in a firefighter's belt area as part of turnout gear, are "a very important tool."
They are used to navigate through thick smoke, locate victims more quickly, help find the seat of a fire, locate hidden fires and assess the structural integrity of buildings.
Morris said the cameras sense heat, and objects with greater temperatures appearing white on their screens. Parnell said it can't be overstated how important the cameras are to fire service.
Justin Scotto and Rick Daya, franchise owners of Charlotte Firehouse Subs, attended the council meeting.
Scott said it's an easy thing to donate funds after fire-related tragedies, "but it's a very hard thing to keep donating." He said Isler and Monroe were hometown heroes reflective of all firefighters who when everyone is running out of a fire, "these guys are running in."
Canisters that accept money on the counters at Firehouse Sub stores go toward the company foundation's donations to firefighters.
The foundation provides emergency services with life-saving equipment, prevention and educational tools and other contributions.
The family of Firehouse Sub founders, Robin and Chris Sorensen, logged more than 200 years of service as firefighters, according to a press release.
What do you think? Post your comment below.
Comments
SalisburyPost.com is pleased to offer readers the ability to comment on stories. We expect our readers to engage in lively, yet civil discourse.
SalisburyPost.com does not edit user submitted statements and we cannot promise that readers will not occasionally find offensive or inaccurate comments posted in the comments area. Responsibility for the statements posted lies with the person submitting the comment, not SalisburyPost.com. If you find a comment that is objectionable, please send us an email to webmaster@salisburypost.com with the article title and offensive post's contents and we will review it for possible removal.
Please be reminded, however, that in accordance with our Terms of Use and federal law, we are under no obligation to remove any third party comments posted on our website.
remember the two fallen brothers : Tuesday, July 22, 2008 10:11 PM
seems like it would eat away at your soul to have to live that day over and over and know the truth isnt being told! its been over four months and no more is known now than the day it happened. someone did send them back in the building that day and they will have to live with that decision. fireman know the dangers but they follow orders and exactly whose orders were they following? its like a little seed that builds and builds until you cant take it anymore. stand up for your dead brothers and tell the truth. you will feel alot better. a clear conscious is a wonderful thing. pray about it.
Report Abuse
MJT
The wrong question : Tuesday, July 22, 2008 12:23 PM
I don't think we are looking at the right thing. So the line was the culprit. Ok. The right question is...why did they continue to go into the building knowing the floor was spongey and that the building had been all clear of any sign of life? Who had them go back in when it is clear from the tapes that they knew several things might could happen (flash overs, floor colapsing)? This is a mill with items to cause terrible situations. It seems to me that the fire fighting should have been done from the outside! I was there that day looking for my husband praying he was ok. Praying that the phone call I got was not true and just a misunderstanding. Sad to say it was not. Someone should be held accountable. The hose was a complete accident and unpredicted but they sent our men back in knowing they were in grave dangers. Jobs or not, brotherhood or not, SOMEONE should have made a better call.
Report Abuse
cant believe you people : Thursday, July 03, 2008 6:10 PM
these are two honorable men. neither one who have put fellow firefighters in any harm. to hear people say anything bad about them, makes me very angry. were you there that day? no! accidents happen on any fire scene. there was plenty of things on the ground that day i'm sure of that could have caused a rip in that line. don't post things on here unless you know all the facts.
Report Abuse
: Friday, June 27, 2008 10:55 AM
Duh...yes the panel would be experts in fire, but Parnell should not be picking the panel. Parnell will just pick experts that are his friends. Panel should be picked by someone other than the people in command that day at the fire scene. "Conflict of Interest".
Report Abuse
Firefighter who is upset at you people.
From a firefighter : Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:52 PM
You people have no right to accuse a man you don't know. Capt. Barkley is a good man, and a great leader. Firefighters don't try to harm their team members to save their own skin. Thats not the way it works. And anyone who says other wise, you disgust me. You don't know anything about the fire service, you don't know anything about fire hose's and you sure don't know anything about being a person. Don't try to blame someone or even demand answers. It's not your place. Is Chief Parnell picking his own panel a conflict of interest? Don't you thing the panel should know something about fire. Think about it.
Report Abuse
: Thursday, June 19, 2008 11:07 AM
Is Parnell picking his own panel, not a conflict of interest??? The Mayor, or City Council should be picking the panel to make sure Dave Treme and Bob Parnell are not a fault in this terrible loss of lives.
Report Abuse
OMG : Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:53 AM
You have got to be kidding me. To even suggest that Capt. Barkley would have done that is totally insane. Investigations take time. Look how long it took in Charleston. People need to be supportive instead of trying to drag the department down. Hasn't the department and families been through enough?
Report Abuse
Cutting the Hose? : Thursday, June 19, 2008 9:39 AM
This last comment speculating that Captain Barkley cut the fire hose is a good reason the Post should start requiring names on the comments. This is a very slippery slope when someone in internet land can start rumors for the fun of it. Post folks, as you said in your post about the comment section...BC.
Report Abuse
: Thursday, June 19, 2008 7:32 AM
Parnell should not be forming his on panel to review this fire. The panel should be formed by City Manager, or Mayor, or City Council. What if Parnell did something wrong, do you think the panel he formed will go against him??? NO!
Report Abuse
To the writer of "how do we really know" : Thursday, June 19, 2008 2:32 AM
Who do you think you are to question the integrity of Capt. Barkley? I guess we'll never know, because you didn't even have the courage to sign your name on your little conspiracy theory comment. I used to work for Capt. Barkley, and what you are accusing him of is completely ridiculous. He is an honorable man, and would never do anything to intentionally harm his crew. Since I'm sure that you are probably an expert of fire fighting strategies, maybe you could explain to me exactly what would have been gained by intentionally cutting the hose line? Unlike you I am not afraid or ashamed to sign my name, Jerry Morgan
Report Abuse
18 YEAR FIREFIGHTER
WHY? : Wednesday, June 18, 2008 8:09 PM
WHY WAS THE HOSE TEAM IN THE BUILDING DEEP AND SO LATE INTO THE FIRE? ALSO WHY IS THE CAPT. NOT WITH HIS HOSE TEAM? YOU WORK AND STAY TOGETHER!!! ( 5 IN 5 OUT ) NO LEAVING YOUR TEAM
Report Abuse
: Wednesday, June 18, 2008 5:27 PM
Wait for the independent reports from OSHA and NIOSH. These ugly comments and accusations show how a blog or comment section allows a single person to drag someone else through the mud. Little positive has come out of this.
Report Abuse
How do we really know : Wednesday, June 18, 2008 3:24 PM
how do we know that capt barkley didnt cut the line to save his life... i guess its a questtion that will never be answerd and i am sure the city is working hard on a cover up this might explain why its taking so long for parnel to put this panel together to do the investigation guess he needs to get all his ducks in a row and get his people on the same page
Report Abuse
Question??? : Wednesday, June 18, 2008 2:37 PM
If the damaged fire hose burned up in the fire, how do you know it had a 4 - 6 inch gash in it? Aren't these fire hoses tested "under pressure" periodically to make sure they are not old and worn out??
Report Abuse
Keep asking questions : Wednesday, June 18, 2008 10:55 AM
Those who can't stomach any more articles can skip them over. Others want to know more. The Post is doing a good job. Keep it up.
Report Abuse
Salisbury Citizen
Enough : Wednesday, June 18, 2008 8:59 AM
I think we have heard enough. Please let the family be in comfort and peace. They need to start the healing process and cannot do so until we quit printing articles.
Report Abuse
|