Landowners in Rowan and Cabarrus counties are uniting in a fight against a communications
company planning to use an abandoned gas pipeline.More than 40 people met Friday night at the Atwell Volunteer Fire Department.
Many vowed to go to court against Level 3, a high-tech company planning a worldwide
communications network.
We want the meanest attorney we can
find, said Jerry Connelly of the South Rowan area. Were ready to start a
war.
Paul Beaver of the Atwell township and his son,
Len, called the meeting, asking others to help in their battle.
They are the first landowners in Rowan to face
condemnation action. If they condemn us, then theyve got you, said
Beaver, adding, They do not have the right to the pipeline without our
permission.
Asked why Beaver was selected for condemnation,
Paul Beaver responded, I guess they thought I would be a push over. They picked the
wrong guy.
They asked participants to fill out forms and
document their dealings with agents of Level 3.
Property owners talked about combining efforts for
some type of class action suits by those who have not agreed with Level 3s
proposals and those who have signed contracts but feel they were misled.
Level 3 has acquired use of a 10-inch unused
pipeline from Plantation Pipeline, one of three used to transport petroleum products.
Level 3 plans to install fiber optic cable through the unused 10-inch line.
A special commission appointed by the Rowan Clerk
of Court recently set a $10.50-per-foot value on the property.
The Beavers said Level 3 has asked the clerk to
throw out the value and appoint new commissioners. A hearing is set Feb.9.
State Sen. Fletcher Hartsell of Concord was
surprised at such a maneuver. Hartsell, who is also the attorney for Cabarrus County, has
handled extensive condemnation proceedings for schools and the Coddle Creek Reservoir.
He said he had never heard of such a request,
adding that the commissioners appointed by the clerk can jolly well do what they
want.
What do you want? Hartsell asked the
Beavers and other participants.
Most said they want conditions and compensation.
Hartsell acknowledged that the pipeline right of way is a perpetual devaluation of the
property.
Hartsell also acknowledged there is a question of
whether Level 3 has the legal right of condemnation. He said the statutes dealing with
that issue are 20 years old and predate the Internet.
Hartsell said Level 3 agents will have a
particular problem in Cabarrus. After a battle with Plantation Pipeline, the lines through
the reservoir property were moved. But only two of the pipelines, those in active use,
were replaced.
There is a gap in the line in
Cabarrus, Hartsell said. I dont know how they plan to deal with
that.
Several of the landowners talked about the 1940s
when the first pipeline was put in.
There was a (world) war, they were sinking
tankers, said Jack Rankin of Cabarrus. It was the patriotic thing to do. We
were going to win the war with the pipeline.
Several recalled watching the construction crews
rip up cornfields. They said most people didnt ask for any compensation, because
they were doing it for their country.
Paul Beaver and others said they had no idea
Plantation would continue putting more lines in the right of way and deed the lines to
other companies.
Len Beaver said at least some of the Plantation
contracts from the 1940s specify the pipelines will be used for petroleum products
only.
Participants swapped stories about the tactics of
Coates Field Service, the company hired by Level 3 to acquire right of way along the route
of the Plantation Pipeline. Officials for Level 3 and Coates have been unavailable for
comment.
Several Rowan residents said they had been told
that Cabarrus property owners have signed contracts and there have been no problems.
They are lying if they said they dont
have problems in Cabarrus, declared Rankin, who owns nearly 200 acres near the
Coddle Creek Reservoir. Rankin said he objects most to the last paragraph that gives Level
3 control of the right of way forever without any approval or compensation to the
landowner.
The same paragraph in the contract has drawn the
ire of Rowan County commissioners, who have instructed County Attorney John Holshouser to
go to court and to challenge Level 3s right of condemnation.
The county is also challenging other aspects of
the contract and has not agreed to the terms.
A Rowan farmer said a Coates Field Service agent
told him everybody from the Mississippi River east to Rowan had signed and only three in
Rowan were objecting. That drew a chorus of scornful laughter.
Larry Mesimer, who owns a chicken and horse farm
on Alexander Road, said he signed and accepted $1 a foot for the 2,000 feet of line that
crosses his property.
They said they already had the right of way,
and they were giving me a dollar a foot for good will, Mesimer said.
Another Atwell resident said he told them he would
agree to the same terms Rowan County accepted. He said agents then told him Rowan County
had signed. But when he asked for a copy of Rowan Countys agreement, the agent
produced a story from the Salisbury Post related to the condemnation procedure against the
Beavers.
The Atwell man said he refused to sign.
A Cabarrus man said his elderly mother-in-law
signed papers and had no idea she was dealing with another company.
Landowners also questioned the fact the Level 3
contract offers no indemnity against liability.
Landowners said workmen have left gates open and
let cattle get on the roadways. They said if a motorist strikes an animal, the landowner
is responsible for the motorists personal and property damages.
Len Beaver and others said they had questioned the
right-of-way agents about including a clause in the contract that would protect property
owners. He said while they were assured they would not be responsible, the agents refused
to add the clause.
Jerry Connelly and his wife, Linda, talked about
the problems of trying to build a driveway across the pipeline on their own property. They
said Plantation required it be built to their specifications. They said they were shocked
at an $85,000 price tag. Plantation wanted the pipes encased in concrete.
With another company involved, the problems for
landowners will only get worse, the Connellys said.
Plantation has us over a barrel, said
Len Beaver. Level 3 is trying to put us over another barrel.
Len Beaver wrote phone numbers for Plantation
officials on a blackboard, urging property owners to call and record their displeasure
with Level 3s agents.
Plantation mailed a letter to landowners along the
pipeline and urged them to cooperate with Level 3. Several names and phone numbers were
listed for calls.
Beaver and others said that all of the numbers
were out of date and useless.