A mans home may be his castle, but his throne better not be an old sofa on the front
porch.At least, not under a proposal being
considered by the Salisbury City Council.
The proposed ordinance, which was submitted by the
citys Neighborhood Improvement Task Force, would ban upholstered or interior
furniture and appliances from being used outdoors, including on porches. Outdoor couch
potatoes caught by the couch patrol could face fines.
In seeking the ordinance, the task force is trying
to remedy an undeniable problem. Nobody wants to live near a house that has a mouse-gnawed
sofa on the front porch and a rusty refrigerator as the main lawn ornament. The city has
worked hard to enhance and preserve the attractiveness of its neighborhoods. It needs a
legal mechanism to continue that effort and relieve neighborhoods of obvious eyesores.
But it needs to ensure that any such ordinance
isnt an un-Constitutional intrusion into private property rights. It also needs to
make sure that it balances the need for neighborhood beautification against the
realization that many people simply cant afford nice outdoor furniture, but have as
much a right as richer neighbors to sit and enjoy the view from their front porch.
In its initial form, the ordinance appears to miss
the mark on both of those counts. In banning the outdoor use of any upholstered or
indoor furniture, the measure could apply as equally to a neatly kept home
that happened to have a chintz sofa on the sleeping porch as to a cluttered eyesore. Would
a homeowner in the historic district with a daybed on the porch be liable or likely
for prosecution?
Then theres the matter of somehow proving
that a particular piece of furniture was intended solely for indoor
i.e. non-porch use. We can just see that CEO of Barcalounger being subpoenaed to
testify on that count.
Beyond the serious legal concerns, however, the
council needs to consider the citys image and its attitude toward our less fortunate
citizens. Not everyone can afford to have wicker furniture for the front porch. But, so
long as they arent hurting their neighbors, everyone does have a right to be
comfortable in their own home, in their own way.
Until the council members can be certain that
theyre protecting everyones rights and interests, wed suggest they put
this measure on hold. They might even want to sleep on it.
But not on the front porch.