The protests in Miamis Cuban community involving the fate of 6-year-old Elian
Gonzalez seem far removed from Rowan County, both in miles and cultural milieu.But as Ive watched, with varying degrees of disbelief
and disgust, the circus surrounding the fate of this child, I find myself following a
slender thread that winds back to Rowan County, and the recent turmoil at one of our
schools.
That thread concerns the role of fathers in their
childrens lives, and the mixed messages we continue to send about it.
While there may be some gray areas amid this
political and judicial charade, one thing seems dead certain to me: If it had been the
boys father who perished at sea if it were a tearful mother waiting in Cuba
there would be no debate about whats best for Elian.
There would be no protests, no courtroom
machinations, no Congressional hearings. There would be no delay.
Had the father died, the boy would simply have
been sent back home to his mother, because we all know thats where little boys
belong.
Yet, because it is merely his father who wants him
back, we can see fit to suspend the paternal imperative and entertain the possibility that
Disneyworld might be an adequate substitute for dad. Because it is only the sperm donor
who survived, a few Republican congressmen valiant defenders of family values
dare suggest that having the right fatherland somehow takes precedence over having
the right father.
And we wonder why young men casually father
children and abandon them. We wonder why so many many children especially
adolescent boys seem rootless, unruly and devoid of respect for authority.
We blame a breakdown of cultural values. We blame
poverty. We blame drugs and alcohol. We blame the media for promoting promiscuity.
We blame everyone except ourselves, and the many
subtle and unsubtle ways in which we suggest that men really arent that important to
their children.
Is a father who sacrifices himself on the altar of
the holy workplace and corporate profits somehow better than a deadbeat dad? When the
mayor of Charlotte deems it worthy to publicly honor a basketball player who has just left
his two children fatherless because he did a stupid thing in a fast car, what sort of
message does that send about the value of celebrity, versus the value of being a
responsible father?
The problem of absent fathers isnt a black
problem or an inner city problem or a welfare problem. Its our problem. Behind the
placid lawns of suburbia, fathers are absent, too. Were just absent in different
ways.
Which brings me back to Rowan County, and the
problems at North Middle School. Having lived here only two months, I wont presume
to weigh in with uninformed opinions on structural problems at the school. I dont
know the kids involved, dont know the parents involved, dont know the
administrators and teachers involved.
But this much I do know: Round up the worst
troublemakers, sit the boys down in a room and I suspect most of the hardcore
hooligans are boys and somehow get them to drop the swaggering postures and
adolescent attitudes long enough to tell you about their relationships with their fathers.
and I think I know what youll hear.
Mumbles, empty stares, embarrassed silences. These
are kids who arent getting fathered in any meaningful way. They may not come from
broken homes, but they come from homes where something is broken.
Mothers can do a lot. Some can even raise up fine
young men on their own, but theyre the exception. A child without a father is like a
bicycle with one wheel perpetually out of balance and near impossible to control.
Theres a point in a boys life
somewhere between 10 and 13, in my limited experience where his sphere of influence
naturally begins to shift away from the mother, to the father. He wants to be with dad,
needs to be with dad. And if dad isnt there, physically and emotionally, it opens a
void hell spend a lifetime trying to fill.
When a parent complains that the North Rowan
Middle principal sometimes deals with unruly kids by giving them a hug, I know where
shes coming from. Ill go to any lengths to make sure my child gets a good
education.
But I suspect the principal knows where some of
these kids are coming from, too.
And it isnt a place where they get many
fatherly hugs.