Worried about forecasts of terrible weekend weather in North Carolina, U.S. Rep. Mel Watt,
D-Charlotte, debated with himself whether to stay in Washington or attend some scheduled
engagements back home.By Friday afternoon,
Watt decided hed better stay put in Washington.
If only the courts could make the same kind of
quick decision about the fate of Watts 12th District.
I keep thinking, any day now, Watt
said.
Last November, a three-judge federal panel held a
trial on the merits of a 1997 plan for the districts boundaries. The focus of that
trial was whether the district boundaries were predominantly based on race and, therefore,
invalid as the federal panel had ruled.
The question went to trial because the U.S.
Supreme Court ruled last May that the federal judges had erred in rejecting the 1997 plan
without a trial. The state subsequently presented its case that the boundaries were valid
and not predominantly based on race.
Opponents, led by Duke University professor
Robinson Everett, argued that race was the guiding force behind the 1997 boundaries.
Watt and potential opponents for his 12th District
seat have been waiting since last November to hear the judges decision, because it
could drastically change again the footprint of the 12th District.
Its so confusing at this point that
theres an overwhelming need for the court to make a disposition of this case,
Watt said.
Here are some of the confusing points:
- At present, candidates who file for the 12th
District seat are actually filing under the 1997 plan, which has never been a real
congressional district.
When the federal panel rejected the 1997 plan, the
General Assembly postponed the 1998 congressional primaries, approved a more compact 12th
District and held an election, even though the 1997 plan was under appeal.
- The federal judges ruling that everybody is
waiting for isnt necessarily an either-or decision. A rejection of the 1997 plan
would not automatically mean the 1998 plan will be acceptable again.
The 98 plan has never really been
before the court, Watt said.
- No matter what district boundaries for the 12th are
settled on, they will be redrawn again in 2001 based on new census information being
gathered this year.
Under the 1997 plan, Rowan County was divided
between two congressmen: Watt in the 12th and Republican Howard Coble of Greensboro in the
6th District. The 1997 district version, as a whole, stretched in a thin band from
Charlotte to Greensboro with a branch out to Winston-Salem.
The 1998 plan put all of Rowan County in the 12th
District, along with portions of Mecklenburg, Forsyth, Davidson and Iredell counties.
Without fanfare, Watt paid his $1,376 filing fee
for re-election a couple of weeks ago. Watt said he views his filing as just holding his
place for now. Theres a chance all candidates will have to refile again, depending
on what the judges decide.
So far, other than Watt, Republicans John Cosgrove
of Winston-Salem, Chad Mitchell of Faith and Leonard Plyler of Iredell County have filed
as candidates. As a resident of Faith, Mitchell would not be in the 12th District if the
1997 plan is approved.
(A person does not have to live in the
congressional district for which he is running, but he does have to reside in the same
state.)
The confusion over the 12th District boundaries
led 1998 GOP nominee J. Scott Keadle to file instead as a candidate for a state Senate
seat. Landis Mayor Fred Steen, also a Republican, has an organization in place to run in
the 12th District, but he has waited to see what the judges decide.
Im very concerned about it,
Cosgrove said, noting that he already has deposited a ton of money his
own money into a campaign account.
Cosgrove predicts that the 1997 lines will be
judged unconstitutional again.
I believe that the 98 lines are going
to hold, Cosgrove said Friday.
Watt, who is black, noted that the 1997 plan would
have a higher percentage of minority voters 46 percent to 35 percent than
the 1998 district.
Clearly, that district probably would be a
bit more friendly to me and philosophically more progressive than the 98 district
would, Watt said.
But Watt emphasized that he won in the redrawn
1998 district and made concerted efforts to represent all of the district since then. He
would be comfortable continuing with the 1998 district intact, Watt added.
From a re-election perspective, I think I
could win in either one of the plans, he said.
Watt described the 1997 plan as more urban in
nature. As for Rowan County, he said he didnt always consider the countys
being divided among two or three congressman as a disadvantage.
If he and Coble were congressmen for the county
a Democrat and Republican local leaders can play both sides of the
fence in trying to win political support for their needs, Watt said.