Tuesday nights school board work session began with a prayer, perhaps the only time
heads would quietly nod in unison over the redistricting plan for the new Southeast Middle
School.School redistricting, as one board
member noted, is probably the most emotionally charged education issue that parents and
school officials face. Change doesnt come easy, and when it involves the future of
our children, it seems doubly hard.
Much of the tension and turmoil associated with
school redistricting, in Salisbury or in Charlotte or any other city, stems from the sense
of dislocation caused by severing ties and allegiances to one school and beginning the
slow process of building them at another. And even when community ties, school allegiances
and the length of bus rides are the only factors involved, redistricting is a complicated
business.
Its much more complicated, however, when it
also involves the perception that some schools within a system are significantly better
than others. Then, redistricting isnt merely a matter of which schools parents would
vigorously prefer their children to attend, but which they will with equal vigor
try to avoid.
One board member, Dr. Ada Fisher, pointed to the
issue of perceived inequities and suggested that it cannot and should not be separated
from the immediate concern of redistricting. As the board wrestles with this particular
realignment, she said, it also should examine the factors that drive school preferences.
Why, for example, do some parents so fervently
prefer West Middle School to Knox, or South Rowan High to Salisbury High?
How do we make schools more attractive not
only to new residents, she asked, but to the people already there?
Thats a good question, and one that the
board has certainly not ignored in the past. Education officials have devoted considerable
time, attention and resources to improving lower performing schools.
But the importance of addressing educational
inequities, both perceived and real, bears keeping in mind now, as the board tries to work
out a plan that both recognizes the cohesiveness of individual neighborhoods while
strengthening the future health of the school system as a whole.
No redistricting plan will please everyone. The
emotional component of change is just as real as the blocks and mortar that make up a
school building.
But every parent and student should be able to
come away from this process feeling that, disruptive as it may be, changing schools
doesnt mean changing educational opportunities or expectations.