U.S. Rep. Mel Watt arranged a luncheon meeting with Rowan County veterans Wednesday to
explain his stand against a constitutional amendment that would prohibit flag burning as a
form of expression.While Watt has forged a
good relationship with veterans here in his work for the national cemetery and veterans
hospital, he also had recognized that many vets were troubled over his stand against the
flag-burning amendment.
So he called for Wednesdays meeting at
Ruftys Market in downtown Salisbury to clear the air. Watt and the veterans had a
healthy, civil exchange. The Democratic congressman from Charlotte didnt back down
from his position, and neither did the veterans, most of whom strongly support the
proposed amendment.
Idont expect to change anybodys
views, Watt said, but he added that his position wasnt that much different
from the veterans views.
Veterans are interested in protecting the
countrys symbol because of what it stands for. In opposing the amendment, Watt said,
hes trying to protect the same principles.
Watt said he has as much respect for the flag and
thinks he is as patriotic as any American. He would personally never express his
displeasure with the country by burning the flag, stomping on it or the like, he added.
But the flag symbolizes the things Americans value
about the country, and one of those tenets is the right of a person to disagree, Watt
said. An Americans freedom to freely express his disagreements makes the country
unique even if one of those forms is burning the flag, Watt said.
His stand against the flag-burning amendment
isnt a disrespect for the flag, Watt added.
It has everything to do with a healthy
respect of the flag, he said.
Bob Yarborough, a local veteran, told Watt that
the Washington Monument, Jefferson Memorial and Monticello are national symbols, not
unlike the flag. And laws protect those symbols from anyone trying to destroy or vandalize
them, he said.
Why shouldnt laws protect the flag,
Yarborough asked.
Could I go to Washington and deface the
Washington Monument? he asked.
Watt noted that laws do protect the flag. A person
cannot burn, steal, destroy or vandalize someone elses flag. But the Supreme Court
has ruled that the burning of a persons own flag as a form of expression and protest
is protected by the Constitution, Watt said.
I dont think theyre expressing
themselves when they burn the flag, Yarborough said.
Another veteran said he likes to look at many of
todays constitutional questions as if the founding fathers were still alive several
years after the Constitution had been written.
Would they have eliminated prayer in school and
hangings for murder based on what the Constitution says, he asked. He doubts they would.
If anyone would have burned the flag in their day,
he added, that person probably would have been shot.
Watt voted against the amendment in the House,
where it passed and has moved on to the Senate. The measure would eventually require a
two-thirds ratification by the states if it gets that far.
One veteran asked Watt why he didnt abstain
from the vote, since it overwhelmingly passed.
It has never been my nature to take a walk
on a vote, Watt said.
Another veteran asked Watt if he had ever taken a
poll of his district on the flag issue.
Watt said he has never taken a poll on this or any
other issue, and he conceded that a majority in his district would support the amendment.
But he saw his oath to uphold and defend the
Constitution as a solemn commitment. Watt is the ranking minority member on the House
Subcommittee on the Constitution.
Things that are sacrosanct in the
Constitution are not subject to public polls, he added.
Marcelle Williams has long lobbied for the
constitutional amendment to protect the flag. He raised the flag amendment issue with Watt
six or seven years ago at their first meeting.
In thanking Watt for meeting with the veterans,
Williams predicted they might be talking about this same amendment 10 years from now.
Interestingly, Watt started his day in Rowan
County Wednesday by delivering a new U.S. flag to Corriher-Lipe Middle School in Landis.
The schools U.S. and N.C. flags were damaged
in a storm last year, and the school asked Watts office to secure a new U.S. flag
that had flown briefly over the U.S. Capitol.
With Watt in attendance Wednesday morning, the
school conducted what he described as a profound ceremony to retire the old
U.S. flag by a proper burning.
Watt also made visits Wednesday to the Precious
Beginnings Day Care in East Spencer, Rufty-Holmes Senior Center and participated in a
forum at Salisbury High with students from Catawba and Livingstone colleges.